Water Intelligence - The Load-Bearing Molecule

How water helps living things stay stiff, tough, springy, sticky and slippery. It is an integral part of life's building blocks and part of the distributed intelligence that uses them.
Introduction: A Liquid That Helps Carry Weight
When most people think about water in living things, they picture it as the liquid that things are dissolved in, a kind of background where the real action happens. This post makes a different point. In many living materials, water is not the background. It is one of the working parts, and it takes on part of the job of holding things up, absorbing blows, bending without breaking, stretching and springing back, sticking surfaces together, and sliding them past each other.
You can see this by taking the water away. Dry bone snaps where damp bone bends. A joint without its water could not take your weight. A wilted leaf cannot hold itself up. Dry tendon loses much of its springiness. Dry wood splits. Insect armor, seashells, spider silk and the jelly inside your cells all behave very differently depending on how much water they hold and where it sits.
Ther are eleven different ways water does this work, grouped in four parts.
In the first part, water acts as a liquid that cannot be squeezed, so it can push back and carry weight.
In the second, water becomes a part of the structure itself, locked into molecules or tucked between layers, sometimes making a material tougher and sometimes making it softer.
In the third, water helps to build a structure, sticks things together, or acts as a dial that can be turned to make a material soft or stiff.
The fourth part explains why these roles seem to contradict each other and shows that they all come from a handful of basic properties of the water molecule.
Several of these ways work in opposite directions. In one case water makes something stiffer, and in another it makes something softer. For that reason the question "does water make living materials stronger?" has no single answer. A better set of questions is: where is the water, how tightly is it held, how fast is the weight being applied, and which kind of strength are we talking about?

Part One: Water as a Liquid That Cannot Be Squeezed
The first three ways all rely on one plain fact: you cannot compress water. Squeeze a sealed bottle of water as hard as you like and the water will barely get smaller. Because of that, water in a closed space can push back against a load, and water that is forced to move through a narrow space can take time to do so.
1. Water Pressure Inside Cells: A Structure Built from Pressure
The idea in one sentence: a sealed, water-filled container holds its shape the way an inflated tire does, with the wall pulled tight and the water pushing outward.
This is how most of a plant stands up. A plant cell absorbs water, and the water wants to keep flowing in. The cell wall, which is made of tough plant fibers, stretches a little and then resists, so the pressure inside rises until no more water can enter. In many soft plants this pressure is three to ten times the ordinary air pressure around us, which is higher than the pressure in a car tire. A cell under this pressure is stiff, and a whole leaf or stem of such cells is stiff too. When a plant loses water, the pressure drops, the walls have nothing pushing against them, and the plant wilts. Wilting is a purely mechanical failure: the walls are fine but the water that held them out is gone.
The same pressure drives plant growth. A cell expands only when the pressure rises above a certain level at which the wall begins to give way. The speed of growth depends on how far the pressure exceeds that level and on how easily the wall stretches. So a plant controls growth by loosening its walls as well as by adding new material. The water supplies the push and the wall decides whether to yield.
Pressure also does quick work. Tiny pores on leaves open and close because the two cells beside each pore take in or release water and change shape. The Venus flytrap shuts its leaf in about a tenth of a second by combining a change in water pressure with a sudden snap of the curved leaf, much like a flexible disc popping inside out. The touch-sensitive plant folds its leaves when a swollen joint rapidly lets water out. A fungus that attacks rice builds up a pressure of about eighty times normal air pressure inside a special cell and uses it to punch a hole through the plant's outer skin.
Animals use the same principle. An earthworm has no skeleton. It has a sealed, water-filled body cavity wrapped in two layers of muscle, one running around the body and one running along it. Squeezing the ring muscles squeezes the water, which cannot get smaller, so the worm gets longer and thinner. Squeezing the lengthwise muscles makes it shorter and fatter. Waves of these squeezes push the worm along. Sea anemones, starfish feet and many worms work in the same way. Even some muscles with no separate water chamber use it: your tongue, an elephant's trunk and an octopus arm are mostly water, so when one direction shortens, another direction must widen, and the animal can bend and reach without a single bone.
Your own body does it too. The soft center of each spinal disc is a water-rich jelly inside a tough ring, and it carries your weight by pressure. Over the course of a day, standing and sitting squeeze water out of the discs, and you are measurably shorter in the evening than in the morning. Lying down overnight lets the water return. The clear front surface of your eye, the cornea, stays about 78 percent water. Cells on its inner surface constantly pump water out. If that pump fails, the cornea swells, the regular spacing of its fibers is lost, and it turns cloudy, which is both a mechanical failure and a loss of clear sight.

2. The Slow-Draining Sponge: Load Carried by Moving Water
The idea in one sentence: a wet sponge feels hard if you squeeze it quickly, because the water has no time to escape, and soft if you squeeze it slowly, because the water has time to drain out.
Many body tissues are soaked, spongy materials. When a load arrives suddenly, the water inside cannot get out fast enough, so it is squeezed and presses back, and the tissue feels stiff and almost impossible to compress. When the load stays on for a long time, the water slowly drains away through the tiny passages, the weight transfers to the solid network, and the tissue gradually sinks. This is why one tissue can seem both hard and soft: it depends on how fast you load it.
The best example is the smooth cushion that covers the ends of your bones in a joint, called cartilage. It is roughly 70 to 80 percent water. It contains a mesh of tough fibers and enormous sugary molecules that carry many electric charges and attract water, holding it in like a sponge that is hard to wring out. When you take a step, the load is brief, and most of it, often more than 90 percent, is carried by the pressurized water instead of by the solid mesh. This protects the delicate mesh from being damaged. Cartilage wear usually begins when it loses some of those water-holding molecules, becomes softer and lets water move through it too easily, which speeds up the damage.
The sponge effect shows up in other places. Bone, the brain and spinal discs all behave this way to some degree. So does the jelly inside your cells, which is a crowded mesh of fibers with water flowing through channels thousands of times narrower than the width of a hair. It takes time for the water to redistribute when a cell is poked. Over very short times and tiny distances the cell interior acts stiff, because the water has not had time to move.

3. Lubrication: Water That Keeps Surfaces Apart
The idea in one sentence: a thin layer of water between two surfaces lets them slide past each other with almost no friction.
Healthy joints are among the slipperiest things known, with less friction than almost any machine bearing. As described above, right after a load arrives most of it is carried by pressurized water rather than by the two surfaces touching, so there is little to rub.
Second, special slippery molecules in the joint fluid coat the surfaces and protect them once the pressure of the water fades.
Third, many molecules in the joint carry electric charges, and each charge pulls a tight shell of water around itself. These shells are hard to squeeze out, because stripping water from a charged particle takes a lot of energy. But they also flow easily when pushed sideways. So two charged surfaces covered with these shells can be pressed together hard and still slide past one another smoothly. The same idea is used to explain why the slimy coating on your eyes and inside your gut is so slippery.

Part Two: Water as a Part of the Structure
In the next five ways, the water is not flowing or being squeezed. It is attached, tucked in or mixed through a material, and what it does depends on how tightly it is held and what it is sitting among.
1. Water Locked Into Molecules
The idea in one sentence: some water molecules sit in fixed spots inside a material, each linked by weak sticky attractions to the molecules around it, and they act like tiny rivets.
In most of a cell, water molecules jostle and swap places trillions of times a second. But some water molecules are held in set positions for far longer, and at those places they work more like a bolt than a liquid. The clearest case is collagen, the tough protein that gives strength to skin, tendon, bone, and blood vessels.
Each collagen molecule is made of three long strands twisted together into a rope, and a neat web of water molecules sits along the rope, linking the strands to each other. A small chemical change to proline, one of the main amino acids of collagen, helps anchor this water. The change is the addition of an OH to proline, which allows water to build hydrogen bonds. That change makes the strands hold a rigid shape on their own. Proline's unique cyclic side-chain structure gives the polypeptide chains a rigid twist, while water molecules and hydration shells act as critical mediators and bridges around these amino acid repeats to guide self-assembly and maintain stability
Drying changes collagen sharply. Dry collagen is stiff but can hardly stretch and breaks suddenly. Adding water restores its ability to stretch. In a tendon, the collagen is bundled in several levels, from tiny threads to cords to thick cables, with watery material between the bundles that lets them slide over one another a little. Take the water away, and the sliding stops, so a tough, shock-absorbing cable becomes brittle.

2. Bone: Why Damp Bone Bends and Dry Bone Snaps
The idea in one sentence: water in bone lets its soft parts stretch, and stretching is how bone soaks up the energy of a blow instead of cracking.
Bone is about 10 to 20 percent water by weight. That water lives in several places: free water in the tiny channels and spaces running through bone, water loosely attached to the collagen, water held tightly inside the collagen and where collagen meets mineral, and water built into the mineral crystals themselves. Each kind behaves differently, and each is related to how likely a bone is to fracture.
What happens when bone dries out is well established. It becomes stiffer, harder and stronger in the narrow sense that it resists being bent, but it becomes much more brittle, so it takes far less energy to break it. The reason is that bone's toughness does not come from having very strong parts. It comes from the many ways it can use up the energy of a crack before the crack spreads: links between mineral-coated fibers that snap and then re-form, fibers that slide against each other, tiny cracks that blunt larger ones, and strands that bridge across a crack and hold its edges together. Nearly all of these need the collagen to be able to deform, and collagen can deform only while it is wet. So water works as a softener for bone's flexible part, which lets the bone give a little and survive.
Bone is not solid mineral. The hard mineral exists as very small units, and between them is a thin layer of organic material: protein and sugar molecules. That layer works like a glue holding the mineral units together.
The glue does not hold by one strong connection. It holds by a great many weak ones. Calcium ions and water molecules sit between the protein chains and bridge them, each bridge linking one chain to another. These are two strands held side by side by dozens of small clasps rather than by one knot.
When bone is bent or struck, those bridges give way one at a time rather than all at once. Each one that breaks takes a small amount of the energy of the blow and uses it up. By the time enough energy has been absorbed, the force has been spent and the bone has not cracked. The bridges are called sacrificial: they are meant to break, so the bone does not.
The bridges can form again. Calcium and water are still there, the protein chains are still there, and when the load comes off, the bridges reconnect.
So the same stretch of glue can absorb another blow, and another. This is what lets you walk on your legs for a lifetime without the bone gradually falling apart.
Water is necessary at both stages. It forms part of the bridges, and it keeps the protein chains soft enough to move apart when a bridge breaks and come back together when it re-forms. In dry bone the protein has stiffened. The bridges, once broken, cannot find each other again. The damage from each loading stays, and it accumulates until the bone snaps. Dry bone is in fact harder than living bone, but it is brittle, which is a different and worse thing.

3. Wood and Plant Walls: Water as a Softener
The idea in one sentence: water slips in between the long chains that make up a material, loosens their grip on each other, and so makes the material softer and easier to bend.
Wood shows this most clearly, and the effect is well enough understood that woodworkers rely on it.A piece of wood is made of hollow cells, like a bundle of drinking straws. Each cell has a wall, and the wall is what carries weight. Water can sit in two places: soaked into the wall itself, or standing in the hollow middle.
Only the water in the wall matters. It wedges in among the molecules that make up the wall and pushes them slightly apart, so they slide past each other more easily. The wall becomes softer and more bendable. Water in the hollow centers touches none of this and changes nothing.
The wall can hold only so much before it is full, which happens at a water content of roughly 28 to 30 percent of the wood’s dry weight. Up to that level, every bit of water added makes the wood weaker and more flexible, and dry wood is about twice as strong under a squeezing load as wood with its walls full. Past that level, extra water simply pools in the hollow centers, and the strength stops changing no matter how much more is added.
If water weakened wood merely by being present, soaking wood further would keep weakening it. It does not. Only the water that gets inside the wall softens the wood.
The wall is built from long, tangled molecules. In dry wood they are stuck to each other wherever they touch, held by weak attractions between neighboring chains. With so many of these small attachments holding everything in place, nothing can move, and the material is hard and brittle, like glass.
Water molecules are small enough to work their way in between the chains. Each one that settles between two chains takes over an attachment that the chains had made to each other, so the chains let go of one another and hold the water instead. Enough of this and the chains are free to shift and slide. The material turns from hard and glassy to soft and rubbery.
Heat does the same thing on its own, but dry wood has to get very hot before it softens. Water lowers the temperature at which the change happens. Wet wood goes soft at a temperature you can reach with a kettle.
That is what steam bending is. You steam a plank until the chains let go of each other, bend it to the shape you want, and hold it there while it dries. As the water leaves, the chains take hold of one another again, in their new positions. The wood becomes stiff once more, only now it is stiff in a curve. Bentwood chairs, the planking of boats, and the curved sides of violins and guitars are all made this way, using water as a softener that is added to shape the wood and then removed to lock the shape in.
Living plants use the same chemistry all the time. The plant fibers in a cell wall are bundles of long sugar chains packed so tightly, and joined by so many weak attachments, that water cannot get in. This makes them extremely strong, many times stronger than steel for their weight when pulled lengthwise. The materials between the bundles, by contrast, are full of water, and they let the wall stretch. For a cell to grow, its wall has to loosen these watery connections. Special proteins do this without cutting the chains, apparently by disturbing the weak attachments between fibers and the material around them. A dry wall cannot be loosened, so it cannot grow.

4. Stretchy Materials: Springs Made of Wiggling Chains
The idea in one sentence: some soft materials spring back because their long chains prefer to be in a random tangle, and water keeps those chains free enough to wiggle back into one.
A rubber band works by an unusual rule. When you stretch it, you are not pulling atoms apart, as you would in a steel spring. You are straightening long, tangled chains. A tangled arrangement can happen in a huge number of ways, and a straightened arrangement in very few, so the chains naturally slide back toward the tangle simply because it is far more probable. The pull-back force comes from this drive toward disorder. Many stretchy materials in living things work this way, and nearly all of them need water, because dry chains are stuck and cannot wiggle into new arrangements.
Elastin is the stretchy protein in your arteries, lungs and skin. When dry, it is hard, glassy and brittle. When wet, it is soft, stretches a long way, and recovers almost perfectly with very little energy lost as heat, which is why your arteries can recoil with each heartbeat without wasting energy. Its oily regions stay loose and wiggly in water instead of folding into a tight ball.
Resilin, a protein found in insects, is the most efficient spring known. It is used in the jumping legs of fleas, the hinges of dragonfly wings and the sound-making organs of cicadas, and it gives back more than 90 percent of the energy stored in it when stretched, in some measurements more than 95 percent. It is highly hydrated and loses its springiness when it dries. A similar material in scallops serves as the spring that opens the shell after the muscle closes it.
Spider silk shows the opposite twist. Its main thread, the lifeline the spider hangs from, is tougher than steel or most man-made fibers. It has hard, tiny crystals made of tightly packed stacked sheets, which are strong and exclude water, mixed with loose, floppy regions that stretch. Water softens the floppy regions. When the silk gets wet, it can shrink to about half its length and become much more yielding, because the water breaks the weak attachments among the floppy chains and lets them recoil into tangles. The crystals stay intact. A spider uses this behavior to tighten a web that has sagged in dew or rain. The silk works only because water enters one part and not the other, so keeping water out of the crystals is part of the design. Silk begins as a thick liquid stored in the spider's gland, and spinning removes water, changes the acidity and stretches the liquid, which turns it into a solid thread.

5. Shells and Insect Armor: Hard Layers With a Wet Glue
The idea in one sentence: a hard material becomes tough, not just hard, when it is built in layers joined by a thin, wet, slightly stretchy glue that lets the layers slide and absorb energy.
The shiny inner lining of many seashells, called mother-of-pearl, is about 95 percent hard mineral stacked in tiny tiles, with only a few percent of organic glue between them. Yet it is about three thousand times tougher than the plain mineral. The wet glue lets the tiles slide, redirects cracks sideways and uses up energy, with weak links that can break and re-form, much as in bone. If the shell is dried, its toughness drops sharply.
Insect armor shows how far the same ingredients can be tuned. It is made of fibers of a tough, sugar-based material in a protein glue, and it ranges from soft, flexible skin at the joints to stiff wing veins to jaws as hard as a tool. One of the main settings is how much water it holds. As the cuticle hardens after an insect molts, chemical links form among its proteins, and a large part of the hardening comes from the loss of water from the glue. The leg of a locust, or the hard wing cover of a beetle, can be ten times stiffer or more when dry than when wet. Some insects add metals such as zinc and manganese to their cutting edges.
Some animals reach almost mineral hardness without any mineral. The jaws of a marine worm and the fangs of certain spiders contain zinc held in place by structural proteins rich in the amino acid histidine, set in a damp protein glue. This amino acid is exceptionally well-suited for cross-linking because its imidazole side chain binds strongly with transition metal ions like zinc. The zinc atoms effectively "zip" the protein strands together, transforming a flexible, damp protein matrix into a lightweight, ultra-hard, and damage-resistant "bio-metal" material without requiring dense calcified minerals.
The threads that mussels use to anchor themselves to rocks contain a sticky chemical that grips iron, producing links that break and then re-form. Because they re-form, the thread can heal itself, and this depends on both the metal and the water around it.

Part Three: Water That Builds, Sticks and Tunes
The last three ways are different again. In them, water helps to assemble something and then leaves, pulls surfaces together, or serves as a dial that nature can turn to make a material softer or stiffer.
1. Water as the Helper That Builds and Then Leaves
The idea in one sentence: living things use water to make a mineral soft and shapeable at body temperature, then drive the water out so the mineral hardens in place.
When animals make bone, shell and teeth, they often do not start by growing a hard crystal. They first make a jelly-like, shapeless form of the mineral that contains a good deal of water. In this form the material can be carried to where it is needed, pushed into a mold and shaped by the animal. Then, as it hardens, it forms crystals and most of the water leaves. Making ceramics by human methods requires a very hot oven. Living things do the same job at body temperature, using water as the temporary softener.

2. Surface Tension and Stickiness: Water That Pulls
The idea in one sentence: water molecules cling to each other strongly, so a thin film of water between two surfaces pulls them together, and a thin column of water can hold a pulling force like a rope.
The surface of water acts like a stretched skin because the molecules cling to each other so strongly, and water's surface tension is among the highest of common liquids. When a thin layer of water sits between two surfaces, it forms a small bridge with a curved edge, and that curve pulls the two surfaces together. At very small sizes this adds up to a real sticking force.
Tree frogs and many insects use it. A frog's toe pads are coated with a thin layer of mucus and are patterned with hexagons that channel the fluid, so the pad sticks by a mix of this pulling force and resistance to being slid sideways. Many beetles put a drop of fluid between their sticky hairs and the surface. Geckos are the famous exception, because they stick mainly through very weak attractions between molecules and not through water. Even so, damp air makes a gecko stick better, probably because it softens their toe pads and adds a little water pull.
The same clinging force explains how tall trees lift water. As water evaporates from tiny curved surfaces inside a leaf, it pulls on the water behind it, and because water molecules cling to each other, that pull is passed down an unbroken thread of water in narrow tubes all the way to the roots. The tension in these threads can reach several times the pressure of ordinary air and more in trees from dry places, and the water is in a fragile state in which bubbles can form and break the thread. A tree is held together partly by the pulling strength of water itself, a property that very few liquids have.
This force can also be destructive. As a wet specimen dries, the pull of the shrinking water films can crush delicate structures.

3. Salt and Acidity as a Stiffness Dial
The idea in one sentence: because much of the water in a tissue is held in place by electric charges, changing the salt or acidity around the tissue can make it hold more or less water, and so make it softer or stiffer.
Cartilage has a great many fixed negative charges that attract water, along with the dissolved salts that carry the opposite charge. Raise the salt level in the surrounding fluid, and the extra salt shields the fixed charges, so less water is pulled in and cartilage becomes softer. Mucus, the slippery gel that lines the airways and gut, changes its thickness sharply with acidity and calcium.
Sea cucumbers show how far this can go. Their body wall can switch between soft and stiff in a matter of seconds, under the control of their nerves, by releasing proteins that change how the collagen fibers in the wall interact through the water between them. The stiffness can change by more than ten times and then change back again.

Part Four: Making Sense of the Contradictions
Having gone through eleven ways, we can now see why they seem to pull in opposite directions, and what they have in common.
Why Water Both Strengthens and Weakens
Water seems to do opposite things. It stiffens a pressurized plant cell but softens wood. It makes bone tougher but softens spider silk. It is needed for the springiness of elastin but is driven out to harden insect armor. These look like contradictions until you separate four questions.
The first question is where the water is and what it is doing. Water squeezed in a closed space and unable to leave makes things stiff, because it cannot be compressed. Water mixed in among long chains makes things soft, because it loosens their grip on each other. Water locked in a fixed position between molecules or sheets acts like a rivet or glue and holds things together. Water between two sliding surfaces acts as a lubricant. The same molecule has different jobs, depending on whether it is a pressurized fluid, a softener, a fixed link or a slippery film.
The second question is which kind of strength we mean. Stiffness, strength, hardness, toughness and springiness are different things, and they often trade off against each other. When bone dries, it becomes stiffer, stronger and harder, but it loses nearly all its toughness, meaning its ability to absorb energy before breaking. That is not a paradox. It is the ordinary rule that very hard materials tend to be brittle. A material that refuses to bend resists a blow until the moment it shatters, while a material that gives way can soak up the energy of the blow. Living things mostly need toughness and the ability to survive repeated loading, which is why most of their load-bearing materials stay wet.
The third question is how fast the weight is applied. In a wet, spongy material, how hard it feels depends on how quickly it is loaded compared with how long the water needs to move. Cartilage is nearly impossible to squeeze under a sudden blow and quite yielding under a steady weight. A wet tissue does not have a single stiffness. It has a stiffness that depends on speed.
The fourth question is whether the water is helping to build the material or helping it work. Jelly-like mineral, steam-softened wood and silk spun from a watery liquid all use water to make something workable for a while, and then the water is removed. The properties the material has in use may depend on water having been present earlier and absent later.

The Few Basic Properties Behind It All
All of these ways come from a small number of properties of the water molecule. It is bent, and each molecule can make weak, sticky attachments, called hydrogen bonds, to up to four neighbors, two through its hydrogens and two through its oxygen.
Water cannot be squeezed, because its network of attachments is already packed tightly. This gives us pressure in cells, water skeletons and the load-carrying sponge effect.
Water can attach to the chains of other materials, competing with the attachments they have to each other. This is why it softens wood, silk and bone's protein, and it is why keeping water out of a crystal or an oily region keeps that part hard.
The attachments between water molecules form, break and re-form extremely fast, so water can bridge two points, let go under load, and bridge them again. This is the basis of the weak links that heal, and of the self-repair of mussel threads.
Water molecules cling to each other strongly, which gives high surface tension, stickiness by thin films, and the ability of a thin water thread to be pulled under tension in the tallest trees.
Water also has the ability to surround electric charges, so salts dissolve in it. This is why charged materials hold water and why changing the salt or acidity changes their stiffness.
And water can wrap tightly around charged groups and surfaces, forming shells that make slippery layers, links between collagen strands, and the damp boundary between mineral and protein in bone and shell.

Pressure Vessel, Softener, Glue, Lubricant, Adhesive and Construction Helper.
A load-bearing biological material is almost never just a solid. It is a mixture of a solid part and water, and its behavior comes from how the two interact. Water carries weight directly in plants, worms and spinal discs. It carries sudden blows in cartilage by being squeezed faster than it can escape. It separates sliding surfaces in joints. It links collagen strands and sits inside the mineral of bone as part of the structure. It softens wood and silk, allowing them to bend and absorb energy, and in bone it turns a brittle mineral-and-protein mix into one of nature's toughest materials. It lets elastin and resilin spring back. It helps to build mineral structures and then leaves.
It glues surfaces by surface tension and holds water in tension in the tallest trees. And because much of it is held in place by electric charges, its role can be turned up or down by salt, by acidity and by proteins that living things release, which is how a sea cucumber stiffens its skin in seconds.
The central point is not that water does one thing. It is that a single molecule, because it cannot be squeezed, sticks in four directions, rearranges in a trillionth of a second and clings to itself strongly enough to be pulled like a rope, can serve as a pressure vessel, a softener, a glue, a lubricant, an adhesive and a construction helper, and living things use all of these at once in the same body.
Asking whether water makes a living material stronger is the wrong question. The right questions are where the water is, how tightly it is held, how fast the load comes, and which kind of strength you need.
The intelligence of water is its ability to be an integral part of all the cell's behavior in many different ways including its structures. It is an important part of the cell's distributed intelligence as it uses water's different capabilities to construct, to lubricate, to glue, to combine, and to soften.




