Search Results
搜尋此網站
以空白搜尋找到 35 個結果
- Single Cell Life | Searching For Mind
Evidence that single cells behaves as if they have minds that experience their world. Individual cells actively communicate with other cells via a complex electro-chemical language that scientists are only in the earliest stages of trying to comprehend. The ability to communicate via complex language is a strong indicator of the presence of a mind. Keyword Search Humans Animals Plants Cells Microbes Organelles Viruses Molecules Mysteries 此語言尚未有已發佈之文章 文章發佈後將於此處顯示。
- Solution to the Combination Problem
QMT is considered an ontologically agnostic theory that supports a panpsychist view of matter from quantum to cosmological scales. What is Fundamental? "Ontology" is the philosophical study of being, existence, and reality. It is the study of "what exists at the most fundamental level of our universe?" It seeks to categorize the basic entities, structures, and relationships that make up the world. This discussion will explore what science appears to be telling us about the possible ontology of mind and matter. Is Mind as Fundamental as Matter? René Descartes’ famous 1637 quote "Cogito, ergo sum" (I think, therefore I am) is incredibly concise and powerful in that it captures the essence of the argument that our minds are in fact the only thing that any of us can possibly know with 100% confidence exists in the universe. Literally everything that our minds perceive to exist in the external world is based on information captured by our sensory systems, converted into electrochemical signals, transmitted via synapses from our sensory systems to our brains, and converted by neurons in our brains into the contents of conscious experiences that our brains present to our minds. That our minds exist is the only fundamental fact about the universe that cannot be disputed. Everything that appears to exist in the external world is literally based on assumptions, interpretations, and predictions made by our brains. A quick detour into the phenomenon of color helps to illustrate this point. Many readers may be surprised to learn that literally nothing in the universe has any color whatsoever. Colors literally disappear from objects when zooming in to look at them under a microscope. Color is a “pigment” of our imagination (pun intended), a property that our brains assign to objects with specific frequencies of reflected light to help differentiate objects to be experienced by our minds. This can be illustrated by the 2015 viral social media sensation “The Dress” which some people see as blue and black, while others see as white and gold (left image below). Credit: Roman Originals dress Stacked block illusion Color is not an intrinsic property of the dress nor of the pixels in the image - it is assigned by each person’s brain when creating our mind’s visual experience of the dress. There are many theories as to why people view the dress colors differently, but the bottom line is the colors of the dress literally appear differently to different people. Another example is the stacked block illusion shown in the right side of the above figure. Your brain assigns the top block a dark gray color and the bottom block a white color. Now place your finger horizontally between blocks to cover the shadowy and brightly lit areas between the blocks and you will see the blocks are now the same color. Remove your finger and your visual experience returns to the blocks being different colors. Your brain is using its extensive experience comprehending light and shadows to build different interpretations of the blocks with and without your finger blocking the center. Your brain always makes its best guess as to the features and spatial orientations of objects, adding colors to objects to enhance your experience of angles, light, shadows, etc. This short detour into color was intended to strengthen the argument that we experience the external world indirectly, filtered through a myriad of electrochemical signals and neuronal processes in our sensory systems and brains, with only a tiny fraction of our brain activity ever reaching the level of our conscious awareness. Our brains gather information about the external world via our sensory systems, analyze the information to identify threats and opportunities that affect our ability to survive, and present the information most relevant to our survival for our minds to experience. Brains can best be understood as organs developed to comprehend and navigate the external world to ensure continued survival of complex multicellular organisms. Brains do not create completely accurate representations of the external world as it truly exists, they create representations that enhance our odds of survival by adding colors, textures, dimensional perspectives, and using multi-sensory integration and memory to make an educated guess as to what we are experiencing at any given moment. The implication of this is that we should have less confidence in what we indirectly experience about the external world than what we directly experience as the internal world of our mind. Everything we know about matter and energy, from elementary particles to galaxies, is based on indirect evidence gathered by scientific instruments, converted into data that is analyzed by computers, and presented to our visual sensory system as letters, numbers, and images on computer screens and/or paper printouts (a 1st stage of information processing). This information is received by the 250 million retinal neurons in our eyes as electromagnetic waves which are converted and encoded into 250 million electrochemical signals that are transmitted to our brains via synapses (a 2nd stage of information processing). Our brains receive the 250 million electrochemical signals, decode them, combine them, analyze them, recognize them (as letters, numbers, and images), interpret what the information may imply, and selectively present the results to our conscious minds (a 3rd stage of information processing). Our knowledge of elementary particles is based entirely on information that was detected, processed, and converted into different forms via three sequential processing systems. Since we perceive objects in the external world as having intrinsic colors which they do not in fact have, we should be skeptical of whether subatomic particles have the intrinsic properties that the trio of sequential processing systems suggest they have. Are We Advocating Panpsychism? Panpsychism basically argues that we should treat the only thing that we directly experience and have 100% confidence exists – our minds – should be considered an aspect of the universe on par with the elementary particles that we only indirectly experience and have less confidence exist with the intrinsic properties that science tells us they have. That abstract information gathered, filtered, and interpreted sequentially by 3 discrete processing systems is considered to be more fundamental than mind is a metaphysical "assumption" that is deeply embedded within modern science and philosophy that should be viewed with skepticism. Jon and I have followed scientific research related to the human mind for decades, and the evidence discussed on this website suggests that mind does not require a brain since it appears to exist in plants, cells, viruses, and molecules. Mind is embedded in matter at least down to the molecular scale. The evidence and arguments get murkier as we move down to the quantum scale in subsequent discussions, but we believe the QMT hypothesis that is being articulated in stages holds together. Couple this with the fact that the forces of nature forge the "building blocks of matter" into more complex forms from quantum to cosmological scales, and the p anpsychism premise of "building blocks of mind" suddenly starts to make a lot of sense. Materialism faces the hard problem of consciousness, dualism faces the mind-body problem, and idealism faces the hard problem of matter. Panpsychism does not face a similarly daunting philosophical problems if one accepts our solution to the combination problem. Panpsychism is also consistent with the evidence gathered across scientific disciplines and fits nicely within existing scientific theories. There is a principle called Ockham’s Razor that is often used in both scientific and philosophical arguments. Fourteenth century philosopher William of Ockham asserted that when there are multiple competing hypotheses to explain a phenomenon, the hypothesis that explains more of the evidence and/or requires the fewest assumptions is more likely too be the correct one. Panpsychism should be viewed as the Ockham's Razor hypothesis for mind from the quantum scale to the human scale. Returning to the topic of ontology, it is worth pointing out that the version of panpsychism discussed on this website cannot be considered an ontology because it makes no claims about the intrinsic nature of what exists at the most fundamental scale of the universe, which according to science is the quantum vacuum. The quantum vacuum was originally assumed to be empty space below the Planck scale where absolutely nothing could exist, a vacuum, a void. That began to change over time and modern science now describes the quantum vacuum as a highly energetic substrate that is seething with quantum fluctuations below the Planck scale, the scale below which quantum theory breaks down. These quantum fluctuations may or may not be physically real as they are treated in quantum mechanics as “virtual particles” that are constantly popping into and out of existence in every Planck volume of our physical universe, regardless of whether particles exist in any given Planck volume. When performing quantum mechanics calculations, physicists leverage virtual particles to facilitate all forms of quantum scale matter and energy interactions, thus quantum vacuum fluctuations can be viewed as powering all matter and energy in our universe. Physicists then “renormalize” (remove) vacuum effects from their equations before solving them because the vacuum creates infinities that make quantum wave equations impossible to solve. The existence of the quantum vacuum as speculated in quantum field theory suggests that any ontological commentary on the fundamental constituents of matter, energy, and/or mind must ground its assertions in the evidence gathered about the quantum vacuum, the most fundamental aspect of reality known to science. Materialism makes the ontological claim that the core of reality consists of a physical substance(s) that exclusively interact according to scientific laws and principles, and that mind is a derivative of matter that appears at some higher scale. Idealism makes the opposite ontological claim, that the core of reality consists of mental phenomena, and that matter is derivative of mind at some higher scale. Dualism makes the ontological claim that the core of reality consists of both matter and mind. The ontological claims of these metaphysical positions have progressively moved to deeper levels of matter as science discovered cells, molecules, atoms, subatomic particles, elementary particles, quantum fields, and most recently quantum vacuum fluctuations. Materialism assumes quantum fluctuations are a physical substance, idealism assumes they are mental phenomena, and dualism assumes they are both. The proposed solutions to the combination problem considered the possibility that mind could be an undiscovered property of matter or an undiscovered quantum scale particle, making no claims about the intrinsic nature of the quantum vacuum nor quantum fluctuations, thus should be viewed as ontologically agnostic. By sticking as close as possible to existing scientific theory and simply offering different interpretations of the body of scientific evidence, QMT remains consistent with all of the major ontologies behind the various metaphysical positions: Materialism/Physicalism: Quantum fields cannot realistically be considered “material” entities, but they can be considered “physical” entities as described by quantum physics, which has led materialism to also being referred to as physicalism. The QMT hypothesis that mind is an undiscovered property or an undiscovered elementary particle is completely consistent with modern physicalism. Idealism: The discussion left open the possibility that mind is more fundamental than matter below the Planck scale, where a universal mind could potentially exist in the quantum vacuum given its ethereal and energetic properties. Dualism: Thought experiment #1 treated mind as a property, consistent with property dualism. Thought experiment #2 treated mind as an elementary particle, consistent with substance dualism. Dual aspect monism : The quantum vacuum can be considered the monist source of both the mind and matter components of elementary particles. So What is Fundamental? At some point in the not-too-distant future physicists should find ways to probe the quantum vacuum and learn more about this energetic substrate. Theoretical physicists are already developing theories for what may lie below the Planck scale, which will be discussed in a future section that is under development. What is clear for now is that the current placeholder for what can be considered fundamental, for what can be considered an ontological primitive, are quantum fluctuations. Return to Theory Page
- Cells are the Building Blocks of Your Body & Your Mind
World famous theoretical physicist Leonard Susskind discusses the difficulties in understanding consciousness from a physics perspective. World renown theoretical physicist Leonard Susskind's 7/18/26 lecture "10 Terrifying Reasons Scientists Now Believe Consciousness Is Breaking the Laws of Physics" 10 Terrifying Reasons Scientists Now Believe Consciousness Is Breaking the Laws of Physics Artist Name 00:00 / 24:33 Click to Listen to Lecture Full Transcript Physics describes everything. The motion of planets, the behavior of electrons, the curvature of spacetime, the decay of radioactive nuclei, the origin of the universe itself. All of it falls within the domain of physical law described by equations that have been tested against reality to extraordinary precision across an enormous range of scales and conditions. There is precisely one thing that physics does not describe, has never described, and has no current framework for beginning to describe what it is like to experience any of this. The redness of red, the pain of a headache, the specific feeling of understanding a difficult idea. These are not at the edges of physics. They are inside it happening in the brains of the very physicists who write the equations and they appear nowhere in those equations. Here are 10 specific reasons why this absence is not a minor gap waiting to be filled, but a problem severe enough that some of the most serious physicists and philosophers of the past century have concluded that consciousness may be genuinely incompatible with physics as it currently stands. The first is the hard problem itself. The specific question of why physical processes in a brain produce subjective experience at all. This is distinct from the question of how the brain processes information, encodes memories, generates behavior or integrates sensory inputs. All of which are in principle amenable to neuroscientific explanation. The hard problem named and precisely formulated by the philosopher David Chalmer's in 1995 is the question of why any of this physical processing is accompanied by inner experience rather than occurring entirely in the dark without any phenomenal quality at all. There is no principle in physics that says physical processes should feel like anything. The equations of quantum mechanics, general relativity, statistical mechanics, and all other established frameworks describe state evolution, probability distributions, and correlations between observable quantities. None of them contain the concept of inner experience and none of them predict that complex information processing should be accompanied by the existence of a point of view. The second is the quantum measurement problem which has troubled physicists since the 1920s and has never been resolved despite nearly a century of effort. In quantum mechanics, physical systems evolve according to the Schrodinger equation in superpositions of multiple possible states until a measurement occurs at which point the system appears to adopt a definite value for the measured quantity. The problem is that the Schrodinger equation itself describes a continuous linear deterministic evolution that never collapses anything. The collapse to a definite outcome is an additional postulate added by hand without any derivation from the underlying mathematics. The physicist John von Noman in his 1932 mathematical formalization of quantum mechanics showed rigorously that if the Schrodinger equation applies universally, the measurement device itself enters a superposition when it interacts with the measured system and the lab containing the device enters a superposition. and the physicist reading the result enters a superposition all the way up until a conscious observer registers a definite result. Von Noman concluded that the collapse occurs at the interface between the physical world and consciousness and his collaborator Eugene Vner developed this line of argument explicitly proposing that consciousness plays a fundamental role in collapsing quantum superpositions. This remains one of the most controversial and unresolved positions in the foundations of physics. But it was proposed not by mystics but by two of the most technically capable mathematicians physics has ever produced. The third is the binding problem. A specific neurophysiological puzzle that has resisted explanation for decades. When you perceive a red apple moving across a table, your visual system processes color information in one cortical region, motion information in another, shape in another, and spatial location in yet another, each through distinct neural populations using distinct computational mechanisms. Yet your experience is of a single unified object with all these properties simultaneously present. Not four separate perceptions of color, motion, shape, and location, but one integrated experience. How the brain binds these separately processed features into a unified conscious percept. The synchronization of neural oscillations at the gamma frequency around 40 hertz has been proposed as a binding mechanism. But detailed investigation has not confirmed this hypothesis as a complete explanation. and the theoretical question of why any synchronization of electrical activity in physically distinct brain regions should produce a unified subjective experience remains entirely open. The fourth is the violation of causal closure. Standard physicalism, the position that everything that happens has a complete physical cause, implies that the physical processes in your brain are entirely causally sufficient to determine all your behavior with no additional contribution from non-physical mental states. But this seems to contradict the phenomenology of deliberate action. it feels from the inside as if your decision to raise your arm is caused by a conscious intention, a mental event rather than being the product of neural processes that simply occur without your experiential involvement. If physicalism is correct, the feeling of intending is itself a neural process that causes the arm movement through physical mechanisms with no explanatory role for the phenomenal character of the intention, the way it feels. If consciousness plays no causal role in behavior, it becomes difficult to explain why it exists at all since evolution would have no mechanism for selecting for traits with no behavioral consequences. But if consciousness does play a causal role, it seems to violate the causal closure of physics by introducing non-physical causes into a domain that physics claims to fully account for. The fifth reason is the specific failure of every neural correlate of consciousness to explain consciousness itself. Neuroscience has made genuine and impressive progress in identifying neural correlates. The specific patterns of brain activity that accompany specific conscious experiences. Brain imaging studies have identified regions whose activity is reliably associated with visual awareness, with the experience of pain, with the recognition of familiar faces, and with many other specific phenomenal states. But identifying the neural correlate of a conscious state is not the same as explaining why that neural state is conscious rather than merely a highly complex pattern of electrical activity in the dark. A perfect neural correlation between a specific firing pattern and the experience of redness tells us that experience X is reliably accompanied by brain state Y but gives no account of why brain state Y should feel like anything at all. The explanatory gap between neural correlate and phenomenal experience is precisely as wide after the correlation is established as it was before. The sixth reason concerns integrated information theory or IIT, developed by the neuroscientist Giulio Tononi at the University of Wisconsin. IIT proposes that consciousness is identical to a specific kind of integrated information processing quantified by a mathematical measure called phi which captures how much information is generated by a system as a whole beyond what is generated by the sum of its parts. Systems with high phi are conscious and the theory implies that consciousness is not exclusive to biological brains but is present wherever the relevant information integration structure exists, including potentially in certain artificial systems or in physical substrates not normally considered candidates for consciousness. The disturbing implication of IIT is that consciousness may be a fundamental property of certain physical organizations rather than something produced by brains specifically, which either trivializes consciousness by making it ubiquitous or profoundly changes what we mean by the physical world. The seventh reason is the Penrose-Hameroff hypothesis developed by the mathematician Roger Penrose and the anesthesiologist Stuart Hameroff which proposes that consciousness involves quantum gravitational effects occurring in microtubule structures within neurons submicroscopic protein filaments that form part of the cellular cytoskeleton. Penrose's argument developed in his books, The Emperor's New Mind and Shadows of the Mind, begins from Godel’s incompleteness theorems and argues that human mathematical insight involves a non-computational process that cannot be replicated by any classical algorithm. Penrose identifies quantum gravity at the level of the plank scale as the physical mechanism underlying this non-computational process. The Orch OR hypothesis remains highly controversial and has attracted substantial criticism from both neuroscientists and quantum physicists. But it represents a serious attempt by a field’s medal winning mathematician to connect consciousness specifically to the deepest and least understood regime of physical law where quantum mechanics and general relativity intersect in ways that no complete theory yet describes. The eighth reason is the specific challenge posed by the existence of qualia, the intrinsic non- relational phenomenal properties of conscious experience. to any purely functionalist account of mind. A functionalist theory of consciousness holds that what makes a mental state the state it is depends entirely on its functional role, its causal relationships to inputs, outputs, and other mental states rather than on any intrinsic phenomenal properties. The philosopher Frank Jackson's famous thought experiment, the knowledge argument, challenges this position through the example of Mary, a color scientist who has lived her entire life in a black and white room and has learned all the physical facts about color vision, all the wavelengths, all the neural responses, all the processing algorithms without ever seeing red. When Mary finally leaves the room and sees red for the first time, does she learn something new? Most people's intuition is that she does. That no amount of physical and functional information about color processing prepares you for the experience of seeing red. If this intuition is correct, qualia are not reducible to functional or physical properties. and consciousness contains something that physics and neuroscience working on the functional level can never fully capture. The ninth reason involves the specific challenge posed by anesthesia. General anesthetics abolish consciousness reliably and reversibly through a variety of chemical mechanisms. halogenated ethers, propofol, ketamine, nitrous oxide that act on different molecular targets and are chemically unrelated to each other. Yet they all produce the same result. The complete elimination of subjective experience while leaving many neural processes intact. The puzzle is not simply that anesthetics work. that can be partly understood at the mechanistic level, but that the fine line between consciousness and its absence apparently corresponds to a dramatic and total qualitative change in the subjective character of brain states rather than a gradual diminution. This all or nothing character of anesthetic induced unconsciousness suggests that consciousness is not simply a matter of more or less neural activity but involves a specific organizational property that either exists or does not. A property that anesthetics eliminate while leaving behind enough neural activity to support many complex physiological functions. The 10th reason is perhaps the most fundamental and it returns to where we began . Physics as currently constituted describes the evolution of physical states, the correlations between measurements, the transformation of energy and information. It describes structure and dynamics. What it does not describe and has never had a framework for describing is why any of this structure and dynamics should be accompanied by an experiencing subject. Why the universe should contain anything more than patterns of matter and energy evolving through time according to mathematical laws. Why there should be anything that it is like to be part of this universe at all. The existence of consciousness is in this sense not a problem within physics but a problem for physics. A feature of reality that current physical theory cannot accommodate without either expanding its conceptual framework beyond anything currently available or accepting that the physical description of reality is incomplete in a way that may never be fully addressed within the current paradigm. What all 10 of these reasons have in common is that they are not the concerns of philosophers alone. They have been taken seriously by physicists, by von Neumann, Wigner, Penrose and others precisely because they represent genuine technical failures of the current physical framework to account for something that undeniably exists. The equations work. The experiments confirm them. And somewhere inside the systems those equations describe, there is something it is like to understand them. Physics has no account of that last fact. And the 10 reasons above are 10 different ways of expressing precisely what that absence implies. I want to revisit several of the 10 reasons with additional depth because each one has dimensions that the introductory treatment could not fully develop. Return to the quantum measurement problem and consider the specific experimental evidence that has accumulated around what is sometimes called the observer effect. The double slit experiment in its quantum mechanical version produces an interference pattern when particles pass through two slits without any attempt to determine which slit each particle passed through. The interference pattern disappears when a measuring device is placed to detect the slit each particle passes through. Even if no human observer actually looks at the measurement results, this result has been replicated extensively and is not in dispute. What remains disputed is the interpretation whether the relevant threshold is the interaction with the measuring device, the amplification of the quantum event to a macroscopic record or the involvement of a conscious observer. Specifically, Wheeler's delayed choice experiment performed in various forms since 1978 showed that the presence or absence of an interference pattern could in principle be determined after the particle had already passed through the slits based on whether a measurement was made downstream. This suggests a temporally strange relationship between quantum events and their classical outcomes that some physicists have taken as evidence that observation plays a fundamental role in determining physical reality rather than merely passively recording it. Return to the binding problem and consider what the neuroscience of split-brain patients reveals about the unity of consciousness. Patients whose corpus callosum, the major fiber bundle connecting the two hemispheres of the brain, have been surgically severed for medical reasons display behaviors suggesting that the two hemispheres can operate as partially independent cognitive systems, each with limited access to the processes of the other. When an object is presented exclusively to the left visual field, which is processed primarily by the right hemisphere, split brain patients cannot name it verbally because language is typically left hemisphere dominant but can correctly retrieve it with the left hand. Roger Sperry and Michael Gaziniga, who systematically studied these patients beginning in the 1960s in work that earned Sperry the Nobel Prize in physiology or medicine in 1981, described the results as suggesting the existence of two separate streams of consciousness within a single skull following the surgery. This raises a profound question. If consciousness can be divided by severing a fiber bundle, what was unifying in the first place and what does that unification consist of at the physical level? Return to the Penrose-Hameroff Orch OR hypothesis and consider the specific empirical evidence both for and against that is accumulated since the hypothesis was first proposed. The primary challenge to Orch OR from a neuroscientific standpoint is that biological systems at body temperature are expected to be far too warm and far too noisy for the kind of quantum coherent states that Penrose and Hammer postulate in microtubules to survive long enough to play any functional role. Quantum coherence, the maintenance of definite phase relationships between superposition quantum states, is typically destroyed by interactions with the thermal environment on time scales of femtoseconds in complex biological systems. While the neural processes associated with conscious experience operate on time scales of milliseconds or longer, a discrepancy of many orders of magnitude. defenders of Orch or have proposed that biological systems may possess specific structural features that protect quantum coherent states against thermal decoherence. A controversial claim for which direct evidence remains limited. Counterintuitively, evidence from other biological systems has shown that quantum coherence can survive for longer than naively expected in warm, wet environments. The photosynthetic light harvesting complexes studied extensively following a 2007 paper by Gregory Engel and collaborators at Berkeley showed signatures of quantum coherence persisting on time scales relevant to energy transfer and biological structures at physiological temperatures. Though subsequent analysis has disputed whether this coherence plays a functional role in photosynthesis efficiency, the magnetic compass of migratory birds is understood to involve quantum entanglement of radical pairs in the eye, surviving long enough to provide directional sensitivity to the Earth's magnetic field. These examples demonstrate that biology can, in specific contexts, exploit quantum effects that would have been dismissed as irrelevant on naive thermal grounds, which does not validate or specifically, but does undermine the simplest objections to the idea that quantum effects could play some role in neural function. Return finally to the deepest question underlying all 10 of these reasons. The question of why the universe contains consciousness at all. This question has a specific non- theological scientific formulation that connects it to the finetuning problem in cosmology. The universe's physical constants are set the values that permit not only the existence of complex chemistry and biology, but specifically the existence of organisms capable of conscious experience and of developing scientific theories about the universe's structure. The physicist Brandon Carter formulated the anthropic principle in 1973 to address this coincidence. We can only observe a universe compatible with our existence. So any universe containing observers will necessarily appear fine-tuned for their existence from those observer’s perspectives. But this reasoning applies only if consciousness is a necessary consequence of sufficiently complex physical organization, which is precisely what the hard problem denies. If consciousness is not predicted by physical law, if it is an additional feature of reality beyond what physics describes, then the anthropic principle provides no explanation for why this additional feature should be present. The existence of consciousness, if taken seriously as something genuinely beyond current physical theory, may require either that physical theory be expanded to account for it or that consciousness itself be taken as a primitive feature of reality. A possibility that changes not only neuroscience and philosophy, but the entire conceptual foundation of what physics is trying to describe. Return to Explanatory Gaps
- Solution to the Combination Problem
The Wave Energy Exchange (WEX) Principle Official Paper
- Solution to the Combination Problem
A pragmatic view of quantum theory provides a quantum framework for the Fundamental Mind Interpretation (FMI) of quantum physics. A Pragmatic Interpretation of Quantum Physics (as posted on Philpapers.org) The incompleteness of physics leads to causation issues and explanatory gaps in our scientific theories at every scale. Logician, mathematician, and philosopher Kurt Gödel developed two “Incompleteness Theorems” in 1931 which together prove that no purely “rules-based mathematical system” can provide a complete explanation of the system it was developed to describe. Since physics is a “rules-based mathematical system” Gödel's theorems seem to imply that physics will remain incomplete unless it expands to include non-rules-based and/or non-mathematical aspects in its formalisms. While the direct applicability of Gödel's theorems to physics remains a matter of philosophical debate, the broader point stands: the persistent incompleteness of physics at every scale — from quantum gravity to the hard problem of consciousness to missing matter & energy at cosmological scales — suggests that the purely quantitative mathematical formalisms of physics may be insufficient to ever fully describe reality. A pragmatic interpretation of scientific evidence should therefore recognize this incompleteness and treat the theories and evidence provided by science as partial descriptions of the behaviors of underlying reality as opposed to precise and complete models of it. With this context established, we turn to quantum theory's central mathematical tool — the wave function. Quantum Wave Functions At the core of quantum theory lies the Schrödinger wave equation, a unique equation used to model quantum systems as interacting sets of quantum scale objects called quantum wave functions. Interpreting what wave functions represent in the universe can be done from two perspectives, what philosophers would consider an “epistemic” versus an “ontological” perspective. The ontological view considers wave functions as representations of real objects that exist independent of observation. The epistemic view considers wave functions as representing the knowledge that an observer has about a quantum system. Quantum wave functions are complex vectors in higher dimensional Hilbert space that have abstract imaginary number components. Furthermore, wave functions require normalization — ensuring that the probabilities they describe sum to one — as well as more involved mathematical procedures such as renormalization in quantum field theory to handle infinities that arise in certain calculations. These mathematical requirements, combined with the abstract higher-dimensional Hilbert space in which wave functions are defined, collectively argue against treating wave functions as straightforward representations of physically real objects. Hence the more pragmatic approach is to take an epistemic perspective and view quantum theory as a set of tools and rules to develop mathematical equations that model the uncertainty in an observer’s knowledge of the possible properties a quantum system would have if it were to be measured. It is worth noting that ontological quantum interpretations such as Many Worlds and de Broglie-Bohm pilot wave theory are viewed as viable alternatives by some physicists. This pragmatic interpretation does not claim to refute these alternatives; it simply offers a less speculative interpretation that avoids metaphysical commitments that extrapolate from an incomplete theory and are not supported by experimental evidence. The Wave Nature of Matter Quantum physics does not model elementary particles as tiny solid objects like microscopic billiard balls but instead as energy patterns that are spread out over a region of space that lack definite properties such as dimension, position, momentum, and spin. Quantum theory suggests that the fundamental components of matter are energy patterns that are spread out over a region of space whose behavior can be modeled by Schrödinger wave equations. It is this intrinsic wave nature of the fundamental scale of the universe that gives rise to the indeterminate statistical behaviors of quantum scale matter. A pragmatic interpretation of “particles” as we know them in classical physics and chemistry, suggest particles only exist for the brief instant when our scientific instruments extract energy from quantum scale matter. An analogy is to think of a particle as similar to a lightning bolt. One could create a set of wave equations that describe the voltage differential between a storm cloud and the earth, modelling the potential energy contained in the storm cloud as spread out over its 3D structure that varies based on the contours of the earth below. As the cloud drifts over the earth, both its shape and voltage differential at each point will fluctuate, analogous to quantum wave equations evolving over time. One could view the cloud as containing a superposition of many potential lightning bolts that could strike the earth in many locations at any given time. At some point a voltage threshold is surpassed somewhere in the cloud which causes a lightning bolt to appear for a brief instant, traveling a specific and classically measurable jagged path through space while transferring energy between the earth and cloud. The lightning bolt quickly disappears, and a new set of wave equations would need to be created to model the updated voltage differentials between the storm cloud and the earth below. Lightning bolts form when quintillions of electrons are instantly stripped from the water vapor molecules of a cloud, forming a plasma that facilitates energy exchange between the cloud and earth. Classical plasma physics can approximately describe this energy exchange while lightning bolt formation is more accurately described by quantum physics, hence the analogy of classical particles and lightning bolts as existing for brief periods of time to facilitate energy exchange fits nicely within existing scientific frameworks. The natural state of quantum scale matter exists as energy patterns spread out over a region of space like a storm cloud, only appearing as a particle (or lightning bolt) with measurable classical properties for a brief instant to facilitate energy transfer. In this view, neither lightning bolts nor particles ever literally exist in superposition of being in multiple places at the same time when not being measured (i.e. when not exchanging energy); they instead exist in their intrinsic wave-like state spread out over a region of space. The concept of “particles in superposition” is thus an antiquated and misleading term left over from the classical physics era where particles were viewed as tiny 3D objects that have definite properties and permanent existence. Embracing the intrinsic wave nature of matter means accepting that quantum scale matter can transfer energy from any point within the region of space it is spread-out over, just like a lightning bolt can transfer energy from any point in a cloud. Quantum wave functions are abstract mathematical models that describe the uncertainty in an observer’s knowledge of the possible properties of quantum scale matter. Wave Function Collapse It is the act of observation of a quantum system that physicists view as “collapsing the wave function” of a quantum system, causing one of many statistical possibilities to manifest into a single definite classical result. That matter behaves in this manner when being observed is not mere speculation, it is a hard scientific fact backed up by a century of experiments. Quantum physicists have demonstrated that the observation of quantum scale matter influences the behavior of the matter being observed, causing it to “collapse” from a range of many possible outcomes to a single definite classical outcome. A pragmatic view of wave function collapse suggests it represents the point in time when the uncertainty in an observer’s knowledge of the state of a quantum system is eliminated by measurement, whereby certain properties of the system are precisely discovered at a definite point in space and time. After the measurement, the wave equations “collapse in their usefulness” in describing the current state of the quantum system because energy in the form of particles was extracted from the system during the measurement process, rendering the prior system of wave equations moot. New wave equations must be written to describe the new current state and future evolution of the quantum system post measurement, using the properties that were measured as an updated set of initial conditions. Wave function collapse simply means that an observer performed a measurement and updated their knowledge of the state of a quantum system, causing the wave equations that previously described the quantum system to “collapse” into oblivion. The Measurement Problem The central mystery in quantum physics revolves around the “measurement problem”, also referred to as the “observation problem.” In standard quantum theory, observation is synonymous with measurement as both terms refer to any interaction with a quantum system that extracts precise information about the state of a quantum system. The information extracted from the quantum system is contained in the classical properties of particles that appear during the energy exchange of a measurement. At its core, the measurement problem involves explaining how the properties of quantum scale matter transition from an indeterminate statistical distribution of possibilities prior to measurement, to a precise set of classical properties post measurement. The observation problem is further complicated by the lack of consensus definitions for what constitutes an observation, a measurement, an observer, a measurement device, nor where the boundary lies between the quantum and classical worlds, if such a boundary exists at all. It is the absence of these definitions that lead directly to the paradoxes of quantum physics, such as the Schrödinger’s Cat paradox where a cat is placed in a box with a radioactive atom. The box is set up such that if the atom decays it will release poison that will kill the cat. This famous cat is treated as being in a superposition of being both alive and dead simultaneously because it is unclear whether the cat qualifies as an observer, nor whether the cat exists on the quantum or classical side of an undefined boundary between the two. Given the lack of definitions, the paradox emerges when cat is treated as part of a quantum system with the atom and poison inside the box, where it is considered to exist in a superposition of states of being simultaneously alive and dead until the box is opened and the cat’s fate is observed. A pragmatic interpretation of this paradox suggests that the cat is never literally in a superposition of being both alive and dead, it is only Schrödinger’s “knowledge” of the state of his cat that is in a superposition of states, meaning he doesn’t know whether the cat is alive or dead until he opens the box and “observes” the state of his cat (which is hopefully still alive!). The observation problem is also the only place in the entirety of physics that even hints at a possible connection between consciousness and matter, where the simple act of observation influences the behavior of matter. Many famous physicists have expressed views that hint at a possible connection between mind and matter including Erwin Schrödinger, John von Neumann, Arthur Eddington, Wolfgang Pauli, Werner Heisenberg, Max Planck, Louis de Broglie, Arthur Compton, Freeman Dyson, Henry Stapp, Bernard d'Espagnat, and a number of contemporary researchers pursuing quantum and/or information theories of consciousness that do not require brains to generate minds. A pragmatic interpretation of the evidence suggests that conscious minds cannot collapse wave functions because wave functions are not considered to represent real objects that could be influenced by conscious minds. Wave functions are simply models that represent an observer’s knowledge of a quantum system. That said, a central principle in quantum theory is that the act of observation influences the behavior of quantum scale matter. Combining this with the absence of definitions for observers, observation, the boundary (if any) that exists between the quantum and classical worlds, and the many paradoxes and mysteries that surround the word “observer” in quantum theory, and the door is certainly left open for a possible connection between consciousness and quantum scale matter. If such a connection were to exist, proving it would require a precise definition for what constitutes an observer that includes a conscious mind, and explain how the observer's mind can influence the behavior of quantum scale matter. Conclusion This pragmatic interpretation of quantum theory accepts the evidence captured by quantum physicists at face value while viewing existing quantum theory and its formalisms as inherently incomplete epistemic models of the behavior of quantum scale matter and energy. Viewed from this vantage point, the mysteries and paradoxes of quantum physics become more comprehensible. Return to Theory Page
- Quantum | Searching For Mind
The etheral nature of the quantum realm is perfectly suited for mind being able to influence matter The deepest mystery in quantum physics is that simply observing quantum scale matter influences the behavior of that matter. The ethereal wave energy of the quantum substrate enables mind at various scales to influence the behavior of its matter structure. Keyword Search General Cellular Mind Dropdown New Page General Cellular Mind Blog Cellular Mind New Page New Page New Page Search Results 此語言尚未有已發佈之文章 文章發佈後將於此處顯示。
- Multicellular Organisms | Searching For Mind
Evidence that plants & fungi behave as if they have minds that experience their world. Eukaryotic cells are the building blocks of all forms of multicellular life. These large complex cells were formed by the symbiotic merger of simpler single cell lifeforms which work together to perform a dazzling array of complex processes to keep the cell alive. Is this evidence of a mind? Keyword Search General Cellular Mind Dropdown New Page General Cellular Mind Blog Cellular Mind New Page New Page New Page New Page New Page New Page New Page Search Results 此語言尚未有已發佈之文章 文章發佈後將於此處顯示。
- Quantum Substrate | Searching For Mind
Coming Spring 2026
- Molecular Mind | Searching For Mind
Coming Spring 2026
- How-Minds-Combine | Searching For Mind
Coming Spring 2026
- Higher Dimensions | Searching For Mind
Coming Spring 2026






