Search Results
搜尋此網站
以空白搜尋找到 35 個結果
- Searching For Mind | Scientific Evidence & Theory
Searching For Mind blogs explores the scientific and philosophical evidence of mind at different scales of nature. Click images to view blog posts discussing evidence of mind at different scales of matter Humans Does the human brain create the human mind? Animals & Insects Could all organisms with brains have minds? Plants & Fungi Do organisms without a brain have minds? Eukaryote Cells Might cells that form our bodies have minds? Microrganisms Could a single cell microbe have a mind? Organelles How intelligent are the components of cells? Viruses Could "non-living" matter like a virus have a mind? Molecules Do molecules inside cells exhibit intelligence? Fundamental Mind Could mind be fundamental in our universe Most Recent Posts View our latest posts Sign up for our quarterly newsletter First name* Last name* Email* Subscribe Contact Us * Name * Email * Message Submit
- Physics & Philosophy | Searching For Mind
Discussion of explanatory gaps in physics & philosophy at all scales of the universe, with a particular focus on the physics & philosophies of mind. There are many unsolved mysteries in science & philosophy from quantum to cosmic scales. This blog explores what science can and cannot tell us about these mysteries, a critical first step in being able to objectively consider the nature of life, mind, and our place in the universe. Keyword Search General Cellular Mind Dropdown New Page General Cellular Mind Blog Cellular Mind New Page New Page New Page Search Results 此語言尚未有已發佈之文章 文章發佈後將於此處顯示。
- Molecules | Searching For Mind
Evidence that molecules behave as if they have minds that experience their world. Molecules and molecular clusters inside cells communicate and coordinate their activity, changing their shapes precisely to execute the processes of life. These intelligent behaviors lie beyond current scientific description hence we view them as evidence of molecular scale mind. Keyword Search General Cellular Mind Dropdown New Page General Cellular Mind Blog Cellular Mind New Page New Page New Page Search Results 此語言尚未有已發佈之文章 文章發佈後將於此處顯示。
- Animals & Insects | Searching For Mind
Evidence that animals and insect behave as if they have minds that experience their world. Mammals, birds, fish, amphibians, reptiles, and insects all demonstrate communication, problem solving skills, and social behaviors that strongly suggest they have minds that experience their environment and engage with other lifeforms. Consciousness pervades the animal kingdom. Keyword Search General Cellular Mind Dropdown New Page General Cellular Mind Blog Cellular Mind New Page New Page New Page Search Results 此語言尚未有已發佈之文章 文章發佈後將於此處顯示。
- Viruses | Searching For Mind
Evidence that viruses behave as if they have minds that experience their world. Viruses are considered a "non-living" form of matter because they lack metabolic processes. Yet viruses attack and take over much larger cells, reproduce, communicate, and coordinate their activity with viruses in other cells. These behaviors suggest that viruses have minds. Keyword Search General Cellular Mind Dropdown New Page General Cellular Mind Blog Cellular Mind New Page New Page New Page Search Results 此語言尚未有已發佈之文章 文章發佈後將於此處顯示。
- Home | Searching For Mind
Searching For Mind explores scientific evidence for mind existing at different scales of matter. This website explores the scientific evidence of mind at all scales of the universe Our Books The creators of this website each wrote a book presenting evidence of cellular scale communication, cognition, and agency that cannot be explained by modern science, which the authors view as evidence that cells have minds. Since early 2024 we have been exploring scientific research looking for evidence of mind in smaller scales of matter including organelles, viruses, molecules, and elementary particles. Our Books Our Blogs Our search for mind focuses on evidence of intelligence in matter at different scales of the universe, leading to the hypothesis that mind is may be a fundamental aspect of our universe. Our blogs discuss this evidence from a scientific perspective, absent metaphysical bias, focused on identifying gaps in scientific theories that fit with the possibility of mind operating at different scales. Our Blogs Our Theory Our joint sequel will present our theory that mind is a fundamental aspect of the natural world. Fundamental Mind Theory (FMT) replaces the assumption that elementary particles behave "randomly" with the assumption that they have the "cognitive agency of a mind." The theory is consistent with the scientific evidence at all scales of the universe while resolving mysteries and explanatory gaps across multiple scales. FMT Overview About Us This website is a collaboration between Dr. Jon Lieff and Michael Rowen, two independent researchers searching for evidence of mind in smaller and smaller scales of matter who joined forces in 2024. Subscribe to our Quarterly Newsletter First name* Last name* Email* Subscribe Contact Us * Name * Email * Message Submit
- Human Cells | Searching For Mind
Evidence that cells of of the human body have minds that experience their world. The cells that form your body communicate with each other, coordinate their activity to keep you alive, and solve problems that post risks to your survival. Your cells electromagnetically combine their cellular scale bodies and minds to form your human scale body and mind. Keyword Search Humans Animals Plants Cells Microbes Organelles Viruses Molecules Mysteries 此語言尚未有已發佈之文章 文章發佈後將於此處顯示。
- Human Brain & Mind | Searching For Mind
Blog discussing the scientific evidence of the human brain and mind. Despite centuries of brain research, no theory exists to explain how human brains can generate a mind. In fact, this hypothesis is directly challenged by modern scientific research on cellular scale intelligence. We believe "all" cells in your body create your mind, not just brain cells. Keyword Search General Cellular Mind Dropdown New Page General Cellular Mind Blog Cellular Mind New Page New Page New Page Search Results 此語言尚未有已發佈之文章 文章發佈後將於此處顯示。
- Plants & Fungi | Searching For Mind
Evidence that plants & fungi behave as if they have minds that experience their world. Plants & fungi do not have brains yet actively communicate, solve problems, and collaborate with other organisms across the kingdoms of life to ensure their collective survival. These behaviors suggest that plants and fungi have minds. Keyword Search General Cellular Mind Dropdown New Page General Cellular Mind Blog Cellular Mind New Page New Page New Page Search Results 此語言尚未有已發佈之文章 文章發佈後將於此處顯示。
- Single Cell Life | Searching For Mind
Evidence that single cells behaves as if they have minds that experience their world. Both membrane-bound organelles and membrane-less organelles have been found to communicate and coordinate their activities in complex highly ways that simply defy scientific explanation. These intelligent behaviors suggests the structures that form cells appear to have minds. Keyword Search Humans Animals Plants Cells Microbes Organelles Viruses Molecules Mysteries 此語言尚未有已發佈之文章 文章發佈後將於此處顯示。
- Solution to the Combination Problem
An abbreviated, less technical discussion about the Wave Energy Exchange (WEX) Principle paper. Beyond Wave-Particle Duality: The Wave Energy Exchange (WEX) Principle and the Intrinsic Wave Nature of Matter Michael Rowen International Journal of Quantum Foundations Published November 15, 2026 The published paper contains 45 pages of technical discussion related to quantum theory, citing 69 scientific papers to support the analysis it undertakes. The paper be downloaded on the IJQF website or by clicking the button below. An executive summary of the paper is provided below to provide a more concise and less technical discussion of the WEX principle for a broader audience. Download Full Paper Executive Summary of the WEX Principle 1. Introduction The ‘particle view’ of matter was first proposed by Greek philosopher Democritus around 400 BCE speculated that the fundamental constituents of matter were tiny indivisible objects that he called atoms. This view persisted for millennia until experiments uncovered a wave aspect of matter in the 1920's, which gave rise to quantum physics and its associated ‘wave-particle duality’ view of matter. While this hybrid view attempts to account for the wave and particle results observed in quantum experiments, it has failed to resolve numerous mysteries and paradoxes that have plagued quantum theory for the past century. Given this lack of progress, the paper argues that the remaining adjacent possibility should be taken more seriously - that the intrinsic nature of matter is not particle-like, not wave-particle-like, but purely wave-like. The paper argues that many quantum mysteries are rooted in the overly particle-centric perspectives embedded deeply within the language of modern physics. .A few examples are that physicists routinely talk about particles existing in many places at the same time, particles behaving differently when they are being observed versus not observed, particles having hidden properties when they are not being measured, particles collapsing from many possible positions to one actual position upon measurement, and entangled particles influencing each other instantaneously across vast distances. This particle-centric perspective may have been useful in the 1920s as physicists grappled with fitting the newly discovered wave behaviors into their existing particle physics framework, but it has since become an obstacle to understanding what quantum physics is telling us about the intrinsic nature of matter. Modern physics appears to view particles as the more fundamental aspect of matter while treating the wave aspect as less fundamental. The WEX principle flips this view on its head, arguing that matter is made purely of physically real energy waves while viewing particles as they conventionally viewed in physics as non-existent. The WEX argument is made in five stages. First, it compares eleven different mathematical models (called formalisms) of quantum theory that all predict the same empirical results and identifies how they differ and what they have in common. Second, WEX imposes a single constraint on the common features across formalisms called spatiotemporal realism, the philosophical view that whatever exists at the core of physical reality exists in the three spatial dimensions and time that we experience in our everyday lives. That the fundamental constituents of matter exists in the physical universe where physicists and their measurement instruments exist. The third steps applies the spatiotemporal realism constraint to the common features across the eleven quantum formalisms which leads to the Wave Energy Exchange (WEX) Principle. The Wave Energy Exchange (WEX) Principle: (i) The sole persistent constituents of physical reality are spatially extended energy waves that can exchange energy with other waves, interfere and/or unify with them, and dynamically evolve in our space and time universe. (ii) Particles with precise property values are point-in-time signatures of quanta of energy emitted by an energy wave and absorbed by a measurement device. Fourth, the paper restates the particle-centric language of quantum physics in wave-centric language in support of the WEX principle, leading to 13 precise definitions for terms left undefined in standard quantum theory, including terms like measurement and measurement device which sit at the core of the central mystery in quantum physics called the "measurement problem." Fifth, the WEX principle and definitions are applied to a series of quantum mysteries and paradoxes from the measurement problem to entanglement to Schrodinger's Cat, illustrating how a purely wave view of matter resolves mysteries while rendering quantum physics a bit more comprehensible in the process. The WEX argument is made entirely in prose as opposed to mathematics because it focuses on the intrinsic nature of matter as opposed to mathematical models of the behavior of matter. WEX accepts the empirical predictions made by the eleven formalisms discussed in the paper as accurate models that predict the behavior of fundamental energy waves, but WEX does not accept their abstract mathematics as accurately descriptions of what literally exists at the fundamental scale of reality. 2. Common Features of Quantum Formalisms Quantum theory can be accurately described by a number of different mathematical formalisms (models) that predict the same experimental outcomes using vastly different assumptions for the mathematical objects they treat as fundamental entities, how the transition form a wave state to a particle state is treated, and number of mathematical dimensions required to make predictions. E leven formalisms are compared and contrasted in the paper, all of which rely on abstract higher-dimensional mathematical spaces to make their calculations work. If one were to view any given formalism as a literal description of quantum scale matter it would paint a different picture than would be deduced from another formalism, and the two pictures may be contradictory. Each formalism was developed to predict the outcomes of quantum experiments; not to describe what physically exists at the quantum scale. This suggests that no one formalism should be relied upon to make ontological claims regarding what physically exists at the quantum scale. The paper argues that focusing on the common features across formalisms share provides a more reliable lens from which to make speculations on the intrinsic nature of quantum scale entities , which yields the following eight common features: "Variable Spatial Extension' and 'Continuous Structural Evolution' are two common features which suggest fundamental entities exist in the 3 dimensions of our physical universe with shapes that smoothly change over time. While both particles and waves can have 3 dimensional shapes, that their shapes change over time fits better with our conception of a wave rather than a particle. An ocean wave for instance changes its shape continuously as it moves towards the shore whereas a billiard ball which is more particle-like does not change its shape over time. 'Discrete Energy Exchange' is perhaps the central feature of quantum theory, where energy can only be exchanged in discrete amounts, or quanta, of energy. This feature fits better with our conception of a particle as a discrete object with a discrete amount of energy rather than a wave which generally lacks discreteness. 'Energy-Frequency Correlation' and 'Interference Patterns' are two features that better fit with our conception of energy waves rather than particles because waves at every scale of the universe oscillate at a frequency and interfere when they overlap. 'Non-Separable Entangled Systems' means that when two fundamental entities will behave as a single unified entity when they have overlapping physical structures. This fits better with our conception of energy waves rather than particles because energy can be envisioned as seamlessly and fully combining to produce a single higher power energy, structure whereas particles are conventionally viewed as maintaining their physical identity inside larger structures when they combine into larger matter structures. 'Values Defined in Space & Time at Measurement' means that fundamental entities lack defined property values prior to measurement and only appear to have defined property values when they are measured. This is essence of wave-particle duality where fundamental entities have the ill-defined properties of waves before measurement and the fixed properties of particles when measured. 'Non-Local Correlations' relates to two independent measurements of an entangled system that show defined property correlations between the measurements that appear to violate Einstein's theory of relativity, which he called 'spooky action at a distance.' This non-local influence has been experimentally verified and the nature of this non-locality remains a central mystery in quantum theory. Defined properties between two measurements fits better with the particle view The five features that fit better with a wave view are features that appear to persist over time while the three features that fit better with a particle view all occur at a point in time called a measurement. Between measurements fundamental entities behave in a wave-like manner and during measurement they behave in a particle-like manner. The next step applies the spatiotemporal realism constraint to the common features. This constraint is intended to be scientifically conservative by requiring fundamental entities to exist in the same physical reality that physicists and their measurement devices exist in. This limits ontological deductions that can be drawn from the common features to the three spatial dimensions and time of our physical universe, explicitly preventing ontological claims related to the abstract mathematical spaces that are present in every formalism. This leads to the WEX ontological reading t hat the fundamental constituents of matter are physically real energy waves that transfer energy in discrete amounts with measurement devices which appear to scientific instruments as classical particles with defined properties. The implication is that the intrinsic nature of matter is not particle-like, not wave-particle-like, but purely wave-like. 3. The Wave Energy Exchange (WEX) Principle The WEX Principle is presented as a two-part claim that captures the intrinsic wave nature of matter: The Wave Energy Exchange (WEX) Principle: (i) The sole persistent constituents of physical reality are spatially extended energy waves that can exchange energy with other waves, interfere and/or unify with them, and dynamically evolve in our space and time universe. (ii) Particles with precise property values are point-in-time signatures of quanta of energy emitted by an energy wave and absorbed by a measurement device. The WEX principle is a claim about energy exchange, so it requires an account of what exchanges energy, which in standard quantum theory are called wave packets. Wave packets are not mathematical concepts nor a wave aspect of physically real particles. They are the only physically real entities that exist in nature. Wave packets are one of the 13 precise definitions provided for terms that standard quantum theory largely leaves undefined. These definitions are provided as written in the technical paper and the discussion that follows will provide some additional context. Wave Packet. A physically real pattern of energy that oscillates as it propagates through the physical universe, can interfere and/or unify (i.e. entangle) with other wave packets when overlapping, exchanges energy with other physically real entities, and exists independent of measurement or observation. A wave packet has ‘structural features’ that include fixed identity features that define its species in the Standard Model and dynamical features that change and evolve over time. A wave packet’s structural features determine its energy exchange possibilities. Identity Features. Intrinsic properties that define a wave packet's species in the Standard Model, including mass (i.e., rest energy), charge, and intrinsic angular momentum (i.e. spin quantum number). This category of structural features is identical for every wave packet of the same species and does not depend on measurement. Inherited from the Standard Model. Dynamical Features. Structural properties that can vary within a wave packet, including spatial extent, geometry, momentum, axis of energy rotation, handedness, frequency, wavelength, relative phase, polarization, energy distribution, and degree of unification with other wave packets. Dynamical features constrain what outcome values measurement devices can read during an independent energy exchange. Energy Exchange. Any physical interaction in which energy is transferred or shared between two systems. Energy exchange alters the dynamical features of both systems, requiring reconstruction of the pre-exchange models to reflect the updated features of the post exchange systems (§3.5). Two systems must have compatible structural and coupling properties in order to exchange energy. There are two types of energy exchange, independent and unifying, as defined below. Independent Energy Exchange. A quantum of energy emitted by one system and fully absorbed by another system where the two systems retain their independence. In order to qualify as an independent energy exchange, both systems must maintain separate energy structures post exchange with no shared energy, no interference between them, and no joint state model required to predict the behavior of either system. This test is physical and does not depend on scale since a quantum that stays coherently shared within a larger system fails it. An independent energy exchange can only occur in the discrete amounts of energy defined by the Standard Model. Inherited from quantum theory. Unifying Energy Exchange. A transfer of energy between two independent systems that results in a single unified system that shares the combined energy of both systems. System independence is lost during a unifying energy exchange, and no energy escapes the combined system. A unifying energy exchange can occur in any amount of energy. An exchange of less than a quantum is always unifying since a sub-quantum amount cannot be exchanged between independent systems. Exchanging a quantum of energy can be unifying when its energy remains coherently shared within a larger system, as in Bose-Einstein condensates (§10). Unified Wave Packet. Two independent systems lose their independence during a unifying energy exchange, becoming a single non-separable unified wave packet. The combined energy is coherently shared across the unified wave packet’s extent, and its structural features no longer belong to the predecessor wave packets individually. No energy is emitted during the formation of a unified wave packet, so unification itself defines no values. This is the WEX definition of entanglement. Energy Redistribution. The movement of energy within a wave packet or within a system of wave packets. Energy redistribution defines the evolving energy structure of a wave packet over time. Energy can concentrate in some regions and deplete in others, dynamically changing the wave packet’s geometry and coupling possibilities with other wave packets and measurement devices. Measurement. A physical process where an independent energy exchange occurs between a wave packet and a measurement device. Measurement produces outcomes with defined values. Observation of a quantum system that does not involve direct physical interaction with the energy exchanged does not qualify as a measurement. Measurement Device. Any system with the ability to absorb a quantum of energy, analyze the instantaneous properties of the absorbed energy at the point in time and space of absorption, and record those properties as outcomes with defined values. Both natural and engineered systems can qualify as a measurement device. Particle Signature. The point-in-time snapshot of the attributes of a quantum of energy emitted by a wave packet and absorbed by a measurement device. Particle signatures are evidence of an energy exchange event, not physical entities that exist in nature. Classical Information. Defined property values that are produced by analyzing a particle signature and representing them in terms of the variables used in physics models (e.g., position, momentum, spin, and polarization). The measurement device's coupling properties and the variables sought determine how the absorbed energy is represented as defined values derived from a particle signature. Model Scope. A mathematical model of a quantum system should include only the components involved in energy exchange up to the moment the exchange begins. Models must be reconstructed after both independent and unifying energy exchanges because any energy exchange alters the dynamical features of the wave packets involved. Including entities that play no role in that exchange adds unnecessary complexity to a model. Under WEX, a wave packet's energy pattern is what physically exists, it exists within our physical universe and it exists independent of measurement. This is no different from a radio tower emitting physically real electromagnetic energy that is absorbed by radio receivers, and the radio station signals exist independent of whether any radio receiver is turned on. The energy a star emits likewise exists regardless of whether anyone is observing it. WEX accepts energy as a physically real phenomenon at every scale of the universe that exists independent of observation. Wave packet identity and dynamical features are not a form of information but instead describe the physical attributes of a wave packet as it exists in physical reality. Consider a coastline as an analogy: it has a shape, it consists of various materials that vary along its length such sand and rocky outcroppings, its elevation varies along its length, and it changes over time due to erosion, human and animal activity, and other environmental factors. These features are not information about the coastline; they are attributes that describe what the coastline is in physical reality. These features exist prior to any survey, and they constrain what any survey could find. The survey records measurement outcomes with definite values and units at specific points in space and time. Wave packets and coastlines are what physically exist, while their respective quantitative measurements are informational snapshots taken at a point in space and time. WEX grounds measurement entirely in operational definitions connected to the formalisms, the Standard Model, and two indisputable facts about the natural world. Energy exchange occurs at all scales of the universe Both natural and engineered systems can emit and/or absorb energy A photon emitted by the sun and absorbed by a photoreceptor neuron in the human eye qualifies as a measurement. The structural properties of the human eye and coupling of its photoreceptor neurons to photons in the visible light spectrum form a natural measurement device that produces visual information about the external world encoded in synapses for the brain to interpret. However, a photoreceptor neuron that absorbs a photon emitted from the display on a scientific instrument has no direct physical interaction with the energy absorbed by the instrument, thus does not qualify as a measurement device in this context. Engineered measurement devices are designed to absorb targeted energy quanta emitted by quantum systems and to produce specific measurement outcomes. A photographic plate is engineered to capture location information. A Geiger counter is engineered to detect radiation emitted by atomic decay. All scientific instruments engineered to measure quantum systems are specifically designed to detect and absorb a specific quantum of energy emitted from a quantum system. ‘Classical Information' is equivalent to 'Observable Values' in standard quantum theory as a description of measurement outcomes, but the two terms carry different ontological commitments. Observable values are derived from observables, mathematical operators that exist in higher dimensional configuration space. Classical information is produced by measurement devices that (1) absorb energy emitted from a wave packet, (2) analyze the attributes of the absorbed energy's particle signature, (3) match the attributes to variables used in physics (e.g. charge and spin), and (4) quantifies the amount of each variable as classical information stored in memory or presented on a display screen. WEX uses ‘classical information’ because its meaning is clear and unambiguous. Observable Value is so deeply connected to Observables in quantum physics that using the term might mislead readers to think some form of value exists in wave packets prior to measurement, which WEX explicitly rules out. Meanwhile no reader will think anything defined as ‘classical’ exists in wave packets prior to measurement. Two nuances are worth mentioning here. First, WEX is a claim about definition and not discovery. Measurement does not reveal a property value that was hidden in the wave packet – the measurement device literally produces the value. Second, WEX rejects the concept of particles existing in any form prior to measurement, only energy waves exist prior to measurement. This means that WEX rejects to concept of a particle existing in superposition of multiple places at the same time. A wave packet is a single extended physical object that cannot exist in two places at once; it only appears to exist in multiple places because it's physical structure is spread out over a region of space. 4. 1st Consequence: No Collapse Postulate Needed In standard quantum theory, a system's wave function evolves smoothly and describes a range of possible outcomes, yet every measurement gives one definite result at one specific location. To bridge the gap from, most formalisms add an ad hoc "collapse postulate" that coincides with measurement of a quantum system and instantly collapses its wave function from a range of possibilities to a single definite outcome. The collapse postulate is an externally imposed process that terminates the wave function and produces a particle at a specific point in space and time. Standard quantum theory does not define what counts as a measurement nor a measurement device, and it leaves open the possibility that merely observing a quantum system might trigger collapse. WEX removes the need for a separate postulate to explain measurement outcomes. A measurement is an energy exchange between a wave packet and a measurement device, and the change always occurs at a specific location and in a discrete amount. Any energy exchange that occurs between two wave packets, or between a wave packet and a measurement device, will naturally result in a change to the energy structure of the wave packets involved. This means that any model built to describe a quantum system before an energy exchange must be reconstructed after the energy exchange because it no longer accurately describes the post-exchange system. In essence, the wave function collapsed in its usefulness as a model of the system. This is the Model Scope definition in action. Lightning provides a useful analogy. Before a strike, there are only voltage differences between a cloud and objects on the surface of the earth below. One could build a mathematical model in which many lightning bolts exist in a superposition of every possible path the lightning could travel. When the conditions of one path exceed the insulating strength of the atmosphere, energy is exchanged between the cloud and an object on the surface of the earth. A lightning bolt suddenly appears connecting a specific location in the cloud with a specific location on the earth below, exchanging a specific amount of energy, traveling a specific path through the atmosphere, then quickly vanishes. The lightning bolt did not exist in a superposition of states prior to the energy exchange event, nor does a wave packet exist in a superposition of states prior to an energy exchange event. Modeling physical objects using abstract higher-dimensional mathematical techniques which treat the objects as existing in a superposition of states is useful because it can make accurate predictions, but assuming that physical objects literally exist in a superposition of states confuses a mathematical model with the object the model is describing. It confuses a map with the territory the map describes. The lightning bolts in superposition model was built to predict where a lightning bolt may occur, and it collapsed in its usefulness after the energy exchange, just like any model of a quantum system collapses in its usefulness after the system exchanges energy. Figure 1: Lightning as an Energy Exchange Analogy Wave energy exchange occurs when two wave packets, or a wave packet and a measurement device, physically interact with one another and have compatible dynamical structures that enable them to exchange energy. An infrared photon detector will not absorb photons at ultraviolet frequencies because it was designed to only couple with and absorb photons at infrared frequencies. A 'lightning postulate' is not required to explain why the lightning bolt appeared, and a 'collapse postulate' is not required to explain why a quantum energy exchange occurs. 5. 2nd Consequence: Unified Wave Packets Contain No Values Entanglement is called unification under WEX, a term that more accurate describes the joint inseparable state described by all quantum formalisms. The conventional view of entanglement is two particles that carry correlated properties that somehow remain linked across vast distances. WEX replaces this with a simpler picture. When two wave packets become unified, their energy structures merge into a single inseparable energy structure where the predecessor wave packets lose their independence and become indistinguishable parts of the unified wave packet. All formalisms model any entangled pair as a single unified object, and WEX takes this common feature literally. Yet the particle view of entanglement appears to resist this common feature across formalisms by thinking the entangled pair retain some degree of independence that allows the component parts to have correlated property values. Under WEX there are no longer two independent wave packets that can be correlated, there exists only a single unified wave packet. Several points follow. Unified packets carry no value because wave packets in general carry no value, thus there is nothing to correlate within a single unified wave packet. The correlations we observe are correlations between particle signatures recorded by independent measurement devices, not correlations of property values carried by the predecessor wave packets. The degree of unification varies smoothly with coupling strength, and it does not depend on distance. Two parts of a unified packet a billion light years apart are still parts of a single unified object, precisely as all formalisms represent or predict. WEX unification is therefore a strict reading of what all formalisms describe, whereas the standard view of entanglement imposes a particle ontology on the formalisms that is not a common feature across formalisms. Much of the mystery of entanglement comes from assuming three things. First, particles carry values that can be correlated. Second, when particles became entangled the values they carry become correlated. Third, entangled particles retain some degree of independence such that independent measurements of the entangled particles will uncover the correlated properties. WEX rejects all three of these assumptions because none of them are shared features across the formalisms. Wave packets carry no values that can be correlated and they become a single unified object when they entangle and completely lose their independence. This is precisely how all formalisms treat entangled particles, that they lose their independence and behave as a single unified object . How correlations appear in subsequent measurements is covered in the next section. 6. 3rd Consequence: Non-Locality Confined to Energy Dynamics within Wave Packets Another aspect of entanglement involves measurements of two entangled particles that are very far apart yet appear to show correlations that defy Einstein’s speed of light restriction. This led to the view that entangled particles can influence one another ‘non-locally.’ Physicist John Bell created a test for non-locality that was experimentally proven, entrenching the concept of non-local entanglement as a central feature of quantum physics. Bell’s theorem is a mathematical test of assumptions about how correlated measurement outcomes can arise between two spacelike separated measurement locations. His argument rests on four core assumptions: 1. Separability: Two entangled quantum systems can be treated as separate systems. 2. Locality: A measurement on one quantum system cannot influence another quantum system faster than light. 3. Realism: Quantum systems carry definite values before measurement that determine outcomes. 4. Measurement Independence: Experimenter choices of what to measure are uncorrelated with the properties of the systems. Bell's separability assumption does not apply to WEX because unified wave packets lose their independence and cannot be treated as separate systems. Bell's locality assumption does not apply to WEX because there is only one quantum system, a unified wave packet, not two quantum systems that can influence each other. Bell's realism assumption defines property values before measurement as real, which WEX rejects because this is not a common feature across formalisms. WEX retains Bell's fourth assumption on measurement independence, thus does not invoke a measurement loophole to evade Bell's argument. WEX accepts the conclusion of Bell's theorem for the separate systems it describes, but the theorem simply does not apply to WEX unified wave packets. However, the non-local correlations that lie at the heart of Bell's theorem are retained by WEX, but rather than the non-locality existing between two independent objects, the non-locality in WEX is limited to the internal energy dynamics of a single wave packet. An analogy for the WEX view of non-local influences can be understand as breaking a small stick into two pieces. The two pieces will have jagged edges at the break point that can be fit together perfectly, not because the properties of the two pieces were correlated before the stick was broken, but because universal conservation laws require that any physical object broken in half must result in two pieces having complementary structural properties that collectively account for the unbroken whole. The top half of figure 2 shows a bi-modal unified wave packet extending in space and as one side approaches a measurement device. The bottom half shows a measurement device absorbing a quantum of energy from the unified wave packet, producing a particle signature at the device and a residual wave packet elsewhere. The particle signature is shown as a dotted line because it does exist as a physical object, only as evidence of an energy exchange. The conservation of energy, momentum, and angular momentum applied at fracture point C cause the pieces to have complementary structures, illustrated in the figure by the complementary jagged edges at the point of fracture. When a second measurement devices absorbs the residual wave packet, it will show correlated results because the particle signature and residual wave packet must have complementary structures that together account for the previously unbroken whole. Figure 2: Fracturing Unified Wave Packets The broken stick analogy is imperfect because a stick broken in half has no non-local aspect, but WEX does. A full quantum of energy is unlikely to be sitting at the location where the measurement device first contacts the unified wave packet. Wave packets are defined by their spatially extended energy structure hence the energy must be gathered from other parts of its spatially extended structure to concentrate and transfer a full quantum of energy to the measurement device. That redistribution is instantaneous and non-local, but it happens inside the unified wave packet. This non-local energy redistribution cannot carry a message because no defined property values exist in wave packets that could carry information, consistent with the no-signaling theorem. WEX is non-local in the same sense quantum mechanics is non-local, but WEX confines non-locality to the energy redistribution dynamics within individual wave packets. 7. 4th Consequence: Weak Measurement Defines No Values Weak measurement may be the sharpest test of WEX. In a weak measurement, a probe interacts so gently with quantum a system that the system is barely disturbed. Yet statistics collected over sequential weak measurements seem to reveal some information about the system. If a value were really obtained without an energy exchange, that would contradict WEX. WEX asserts the probe obtains no value during a weak measurement, no partial value, and no hidden value. No value whatsoever. The probe and system exchange less than a full quantum of energy and have minimally overlapping wave packets, meaning they form a minimally unified wave packet. Energy shifts around inside the unified packet but no energy is emitted, thus no particle signature is produced to define property values. Values appear only later, when the weak probe is absorbed by a detector. That measurement extracts a quantum of energy from the unified packet, defining the probe's values in its particle signature, and constrains the residual wave packet via conservation laws, much like the fracture described in the prior section. The system was not weakly measured by the probe, their energy structures changed slightly from the minimal interaction, and the change limits what later measurements can find. 8. 5th Consequence: One Description of Extended Structures The famous double-slit experiment sends a series of single photons toward a barrier with two slits. As photon hits accumulate on a screen, an interference pattern appears as if each photon had gone through both slits. Under WEX, that is exactly what happens. Each photon is a single wave packet that passes through both slits, emerges on the other side of the two-slit barrier as a bimodal wave packet, proceeds to overlap and interfere with itself as it approaches the screeen, and then exchanges its energy with the screen at a single location. Place an absorbing detector at either slit causes the interference pattern to disappear. The traditional story says the photon was forced to reveal its particle nature while WEX says the detector absorbed the photon's whole quantum at that slit, leaving no residual for the screen to absorb. The detector did not find a particle as it simply ended the wave packet's journey and produced a particle signature, evidence that the photon’s energy was absorbed by the detector. Block one slit, and the wave packet passes only through the other slit and no interference pattern builds on the screen because the wave packet doesn’t interfere with itself because its extended structure did not pass through both slits. As discussed previously, the energy inside the bimodal wave packet is instantly redistributed from throughout its spatial extent when it transfers its energy to a slit detector or the screen, whichever it encounters first. Wheeler's delayed-choice version sharpens the puzzle. The decision about how to detect the photon is made after it has passed the two slits. With a screen in place, you get interference. With the screen removed, two telescopes aimed at the two slits reveal "which slit" information about the slit each photon passes though. The puzzle asks how a measurement choice made after the photon passed the slits can reveal whether the photon passed through one slit or produced a wave interference pattern? Under WEX, the photon always passes through both slits and emerges as an extended bi-modal wave packet that interferes with itself on the other side of the slits. The telescopes are designed to detect photons arriving from the slit it is aimed at, so any absorption necessarily looks like a which-slit result. The which-slit information comes from the detection geometry of the telescope, not from a measurement choice made after the photon passed the slits. Single-photon experiments conducted using an interferometer confirmed the predicted results, and WEX explains them without retro-causality because no earlier fact exists for a later choice to overturn. As with any spatially extended wave packet, the energy that is spread throughout its spatial extent will be instantly redistributed and transferred to the first measurement device it encounters. 9. 6th Consequence: Observer Paradoxes Dissolve Schrödinger's cat, Wigner's friend, and the Frauchiger-Renner thought experiment all arise from the lack of a formal definition to define the scope of a quantum system when building a model of the system. WEX supplies one in its definition of 'Model Scope', which simply states that any model of a quantum should only include objects that are directly involved in the next energy exchange the system will encounter. This eliminates observers and measurement devices from being included in the model for any quantum system, which resolves all observer-based paradoxes from the start. The Schrödinger's cat paradox involves a radioactive atom, a Geiger counter, a vial of poison, and a cat inside a sealed box. When the atom decays, the Geiger counter records the event, which triggers a mechanism to break the bottle, release the poison, which kills the cat. Under WEX's Model Scope definition, only the atom's internal structure is directly involved in determining the timing of its radioactive decay, thus the proper model scope for the experiment is the atom alone, and its probability of decay determines the fate of the cat. The Geiger counter, vial, and cat should be excluded from the model of the system because they have no influence on when the atom decays. The cat is always either alive or dead, never in a superposition of being both alive and dead at the same time. Consider tomorrow's weather forecast. The prediction model for a storm does not include the people who will view the forecast, and nobody concludes that people are walking around town in a superposition of umbrella-carrying and not umbrella-carrying states. Leaving the people and their umbrellas out of the weather model is not a statement that people are exempt from physics or weather, it is a decision about the relevant scope of what should be included in a mathematical model of any system. Only things that can actually influence the phenomena being modeled should be included in a model of a system. 10. 7th Consequence: No Quantum Boundary A common assumption is that the quantum world gives way to a classical world at some size or complexity, neither of which has been defined by standard quantum theory. If matter is wave-like all the way down as posited by WEX, then no such boundary is needed. The prior section discussion about which objects belong in the model of a quantum system is a scoping rule, not a rule of nature. There is no boundary between the quantum and classical worlds in WEX since wave packet energy dynamics apply at every scale. Experiments support this. Wave behavior has been seen in molecules with thousands of atoms and in mechanical resonators made of trillions of supercooled atoms. Bose-Einstein condensates are clouds of many atoms that behave as a single unified wave packet that produces clean interference fringes when two of them overlap. Biology may be involved as well, with reports of quantum effects in photosynthesis and in the magnetic compass sense of migratory birds, though these remain active areas of research as opposed to settled science. Why, then, do everyday objects look classical? Large objects constantly exchange energy internally and with their surroundings, so it becomes extremely hard for any instrument to isolate and absorb the particular quanta needed to show their wave behavior. Imagine trying to hear a friend playing their violin in a stadium concert featuring 100 violinists playing simultaneously. Your friend’s violin is certainly playing musical notes, but the aggregate music from 100 violins plus 1,000 other instruments playing simultaneously masks your ability to hear your friend musical notes. The practical limit in detecting quantum dynamics in macroscopic forms of matter is in our scientific instrument’s ability to discriminate quantum wave effects from background noise, not a scale or complexity limit where quantum dynamics cease to exist. The same wave dynamics extend to the largest scales of the universe. Stars and the solar wind are plasmas, in which waves and resonant energy exchange between waves and charged particles are part of standard plasma physics. Fusion in the Sun's core depends on quantum tunneling despite extreme heat and density, so intense conditions do not extinguish quantum dynamics. In condensed matter physics, collective vibrations such as phonons behave like quantized units of energy in the crystal's modes. Quantum field theory even predicts that black hole horizons emit thermal radiation, which extends quantum dynamics to the most massive objects in the known universe. In most of these cases, standard physics already accounts for the data, so these examples illustrate WEX but do not distinguish it from standard theory. The point is that nothing in physics tells us where wave packet energy exchange should stop, and WEX asserts that there is no boundary where quantum dynamics cease. 11. 8th Consequence: Quantum Information Theory as Information Production Quantum Information Theory (QIT) studies how quantum systems store, process, and transmit information. It typically treats "quantum information" as something that is encoded in a quantum state, thus is defined in an abstract mathematical space. Its results are well established, and WEX does not dispute them. What WEX changes is the interpretation. A theorem known as the Pusey-Barrett-Rudolph result shows that, under a reasonable assumption about how independently prepared systems behave, quantum states cannot represent mere information about some deeper reality but must correspond to something physically real. WEX supplies an answer: quantum states are mathematical representations of physically real wave packets. Much of this discussion has focused on the WEX view that property values are not carried in wave packets, which also means information is not carried in wave packets. A wave packet has structural facts, not any form of stored value. This means that information is not 'discovered' in quantum systems during measurement but rather information is ‘produced’ when a measurement device maps the attributes of an energy exchange particle signature to the quantitative variables of physics, stores their values in memory and displays them on screens. WEX views QIT as the science of how wave packet structure limits and shapes the classical information that measurements can produce, not the study of quantum information waiting to be discovered. A more comprehensive discussion of QIT is contained in the full WEX paper, including topics such as quantum teleportation, entanglement swapping, the Helovo bound, entanglement entropy, and the no closing theorem. In each case, WEX provides physical explanations for phenomena that are highly abstract from the vantage point of standard quantum information theory. 12. 9th Consequence: Quantum Computers Leverage Geometric Computing Quantum computers are often described as trying every answer at once because their qubits are "in superposition" of many states. WEX offers a different picture that incorporates the physics of the hardware. The hardware is a wave packet, and the software is a sequence of carefully controlled sub-quantum interactions that reshape it. A classical computer's transistors have two binary states. A unified computational wave packet is a single structure with a continuum of possible shapes, and quantum algorithms produce controlled sub-quantum energy exchanges with the unified packet that alters its geometry without releasing a quantum of energy that would result in a particle signature. An analogy is sculpting. A sculptor does not carve every possible statue and then pick one. Each cut constrains the shape of the next, and the finished form carries the effect of every cut. A quantum algorithm likewise imposes a sequence of constraints that steer the packet's structure toward one in which a geometrically optimized answer appears in the final measurement particle signature as classical information. Under WEX, the power of quantum computing comes from the continuum of geometric degrees of freedom of wave packet structure, not from a computer doing many calculations at once in our universe or possibly in parallel universes. WEX offers an alternative hypothesis for why and how quantum computers work, that they utilize a form of geometric computing. 13. 10th Consequence: Universality Across Scale, Formalism, and Geometry WEX claims to be universal in three ways. The first is that it is formalism independence. Because it rests on features shared by eleven different mathematical frameworks, it does not depend on any one of them. The second is scale independence as Section 10 argued. Nothing in any formalism nor in physics more broadly suggests that wave packet energy dynamics should cease at any scale or complexity of the universe. The third is geometry independence. The paper largely developed WEX using ordinary non-relativistic quantum theory examples for clarity purposes, but nothing in the WEX principle requires this limitation. Relativistic versions of the formalism are consistent with WEX. In relativistic quantum theory, an accelerating detector can register wave energy exchanges in a vacuum where a detector at rest registers none. That is puzzling if particles are objects that exist independent of detectors, but it is expected under WEX where a particle signature is simply a record of a wave energy exchange with a particular detector. WEX remains neutral about whether wave packets exist only in the familiar dimensions of our space and time physical universe. Some current research suggests that space and time may emerge from something more fundamental beneath the Planck scale, and other research posits additional physical dimensions in pursuit of a quantum theory of gravity. Whether wave packets extend into extra dimensions or into a deeper layer of reality does not impact the WEX Principle because the core insight is not technical, but metaphysical. The fundamental constituents of our reality are physically real wave energy patterns while particles as they are conventionally understood in science simply do not exist. 14. Conclusion Eleven of the most utilized quantum formalisms widely diverge in their abstract mathematical models, yet they all directly represent or predict the same eight core features of fundamental entities. Viewing these common features with a constraint that requires whatever exists at the fundamental scale exists in the three spatial dimensions plus time where physicists and their measurement devices exist leads to the WEX principle: The Wave Energy Exchange (WEX) Principle: (i) The sole persistent constituents of physical reality are spatially extended energy waves that can exchange energy with other waves, interfere and/or unify with them, and dynamically evolve in our space and time universe. (ii) Particles with precise property values are point-in-time signatures of quanta of energy emitted by an energy wave and absorbed by a measurement device. Ten consequences were traced through the mysteries of quantum physics, and in every case the simpler explanation was rooted in the WEX wave-only perspective, not in the wave-particle perspective. Collapse is replaced by energy exchange, entanglement by unification, and Bell violations are explained by conservation laws acting on a single extended object. Weak measurement, the double-slit experiment, and delayed choice are all described without hidden property values or backward causation. Observer paradoxes dissolve once model scope is properly defined around energy exchange. The quantum-classical boundary disappears as every star, planet, organism, cell, molecule, atom and subatomic particle consists entirely of physically real, spatially extended, interacting wave energy patterns. WEX does not address every mystery in quantum physics. The measurement problem is only partly resolved because WEX does not explain why an energy exchange happens at one location versus another (WEX inherits the Born rule for this) nor does it explain why energy is exchanged in discrete quanta (WEX inherits the Standard Model for this). WEX also does not explain non-locality but does constrain it to the internal energy dynamics of individual fundamental entities. A century of quantum theory and experiments grounded in wave-particle duality has failed to resolve numerous quantum and paradoxes. It is time to consider the intrinsic wave nature of matter as an promising path forward in quantum theory. Return to Theory Page Susskind
- Theory | Searching For Mind
The Fundamental Mind Interpretation (FMI) of physics uses scientific evidence to build an argument for mind as a fundamental aspect of our universe. Fundamental Mind Theory Fundamental Mind Theory (FMT) is a scientific theory that posits mind as a non-random cognitive agency embedded within quantum scale matter that progressively combines to form more complex minds in more complex forms of matter. By replacing quantum randomness with cognitive agency, FMT offers a coherent framework that resolves explanatory gaps that arise from randomness assumptions at multiple scales of reality. FMT remains compatible with the metaphysical views of physicalism, panpsychism, dualism, and idealism by using scientific arguments to move the debate on ontology of mind to the quantum scale. This page represents FMT's current hypothesis which will evolve as FMT is further developed. The complete theory is expected to be published in a 2028 joint sequel to our books. Cells Have Minds That Combine Our books discuss research illustrating that cells communicate, collaborate, and solve problems, which we view as demonstrating cognition and agency that we define as cellular scale mind. Your 30 trillion cells electromagnetically combine their cellular scale minds to form your human scale mind. This hypothesis resolves numerous problems in neuroscience, cell biology, and evolution while addressing longstanding mysteries in philosophy of mind. Cellular Scale Mind How Minds Combine Asserting that minds can combine faces the classic "Combination Problem" which asks whether and how science can explain how minds might combine. Two solutions are offered which show that the fundamental forces of nature and universal conservation laws enable mind combination if mind is assumed to be an undiscovered quantum property, particle, or field. These solutions form the 1st of 4 foundational pillars that support FMT. Minds Combine via Forces of Nature How Minds Combine Physics is Incomplete While science provides incredibly accurate models of the behavior of matter and energy at different scales of the universe, it also remains incomplete as evidenced by explanatory gaps and causation problems in our scientific theories at every scale. The broad scope of this incompleteness across scales argues for taking a cautious approach when interpreting what our scientific theories imply about the intrinsic nature of reality. Science is Incomplete at All Scales Science is Incomplete Quantum Framework The Wave Energy Exchange (WEX) principle argues t he mysteries of quantum physics stem from an unwillingness to give up on particles as fundamental entities despite evidence suggesting the intrinsic nature of matter is wave-like. WEX forms the 2nd pillar of FMT by embodying quantum scale matter with a physically real energy structure that exists within the dimensions of our physical universe rather than in abstract mathematical dimensions. The Intrinsic Wave Nature of Reality The WEX Principle Random Assumptions Explanatory Gaps as Signs of Intelligence When scientists encounter phenomena that existing scientific theories do not fully explain, they often attribute them to chance, emergence, self-assembly, epigenetics, and other loosely defined terms that obscure the fact that the underlying cause remains unexplained. These explanatory gaps exist from quantum to cosmological scales, and could be viewed as a sign of an intelligence in matter that science does not recognize. Explanatory Gaps Coming 2027 Molecular Mind Evidence of Mind at Molecular Scale Molecules and viruses inside cells communicate, collaborate, and exhibit goal-directed behaviors. FMT explains these behaviors as driven by molecular scale minds while the prevailing scientific hypothesis relies on chance or unidentified causal mechanisms to drive molecular behavior. The subcellular world is best understood as a complex society of molecules with minds that collaborate to keep their shared ecosystem functioning properly. Molecular Scale Mind Coming 2027 Mind-Matter Quantum Scale Cognitive Agents The 3rd pillar of FMT involves replacing the randomness assumption at the quantum scale with a cognitive agency (mind) embedded in the energy waves that form matter. This single assumption resolves multiple explanatory gaps that result from random behavior assumptions at the molecular, cellular, and organism scales while dissolving the mind-body problem and other longstanding mysteries in philosophy of mind. Quantum Scale Mind Coming 2027 Evolution Mind as the Driver of Evolution Matter evolves increasingly complex structure and behavior as it scales from atoms to cells to organisms with brains, creating explanatory gaps in physics, thermodynamics, biology, and evolution theory. Evolution is assumed to be driven by random mutations filtered by natural selection while FMT posits that mind drives the evolution of more complex matter to enable more advanced intelligence that can better comprehend the universe. Mind Driven Evolution Coming 2027 Anchor 1 Substratum Physics as the Next Frontier The quantum vacuum grounds, powers, and connects all matter and energy in the universe, facilitates all energy transfer, and powers the expansion of the universe. T his 'substratum' beneath the Planck Scale can be theoretically modeled but empirical study requires orders of magnitude advancements in our scientific instruments. Fundamental Reality Coming 2028 Fundamental Mind Fundamental Mind in Quantum Substratum The 4th and final pillar of FMT is the hypothesis that the quantum substratum not only grounds, powers, and connects all matter and energy in the universe, but all mind as well. The implications of mind existing at the fundamental scale of reality are far reaching and paint an inspiring picture of the universe and our place within it. Fundamental Mind Coming 2028 The FMT blog contains posts that assume the reader is familiar with the hypothesis presented on this page. View the FMT Blog Contact Us * Name * Email * Message Submit Subscribe to our Quarterly Newsletter First name* Last name* Email* Subscribe











